Nuance, undertones, rhetorical questions may as well as not exist for some of these good fellows. I must remind myself that even though someone (many someones) might lack in this department, that doesn’t mean they aren’t brighter than me in many other things.
I am curious though. How, if you are aware of this, do you watch spy, palace intrigue, double agent, psychological movies? Isn’t it detrimental to fully enjoy the acting and reading actors expressions and nuances? I guess you wouldn’t be aware that you are missing full experience?
——
It’s not about me by the way, it is from the perspective of a spectator, a lurker and not about me receiving some kind of response.
You’re on an alternate social media service, which basically caters to the tech-savvy. Most of us are on the spectrum one way or another. Sarcasm and tone are hard to identify in text.
I can get it when it’s missing political satire, just because there are some really stupid ideas genuinely going around; but I’ve seen a lot of missing just the most absurd jokes about fictional topics that I sometimes wonder the same thing about how they would react to a slapstick comedy.
“No no no… This is all wrong. There’s no way the coyote would just float in the air until he looked down. Totally unrealistic.”
You’re forgetting that text is a lot harder to “read” than when you’re saying it in person. There’s no tone, or body language to observe.
For sure this. I had thought it was broadly understood 😬
I assume a large percentage of Lemmy users have the 'tism.
I like to think I have it too cause otherwise I would have to consider other less interesting options lmao
I once got blasted to hell on a Onion News post, for saying “the onion has lost a credibility lately”. An obvious reference (so i thought) to the fact that the news are stranger than fiction these days. No kidding dozens of persons got mad at me for this…We live in a world that is sorely lacking in nuance and where people based their opinions on memes.
Written communication between strangers is going to lead to a lot of missed subtlety. Without shared context it’s not always obvious when someone is joking, the Internet is full of crazies of every stripe, so even obviously extreme ideas are not definitely satire.
I’m not sure lemmy seems worse than anywhere else tbh, but it does have a larger international user base. No native English speakers, and people from different cultures, are going to lead to more breakdowns in nuance.
Not meaning to imply anything to OP’s abilities, but part of the effectiveness of any communication is the delivery. Some people don’t get satire or other implied meanings even in person. Text is harder to do unless the reader is familiar with references or is in the same “mode” of humor at the time. Sometimes to make a joke or twist work online means you have to put a bit more background or setup than you would in other settings. I’ve done the same, where I just type out a phrase or quote or line as I would IRL, and then realize that it’s not that funny without a bit of context added to help it.
Note an example is the very first part I added so OP didn’t think I was saying they were bad at satire. In real conversation I might not have to say that because it’s implied we’re talking about generalities and not them. Or adding /s to a joke that could be taken serious, or other emotes to create a setting for the punchline.
I think (and this is just my opinion based on years of seeing online discussions) that people are quick to type in their thoughts and hit send without reading over and editing things for clarify. That leads to misunderstandings which fuels the typical arguments we find all because of missing nuances. Hell, I’ve even read over things, submitted a post, and then gone right back to edit because I saw something else needed.
Hell, I’ve even read over things, submitted a post, and then gone right back to edit because I saw something else needed.
/s
It’s not about my ability this time or lack of it tho.
I am talking about just lurking and seeing other people responses and certain… rigidity. Responding in stiff manner, official speech, missing nuance, explaining something that didn’t need to be explained.
I just generally feel a lot of the times like someone who sees these notorious miscommunications so to say when just spectating various comments.
Best I can describe is that there are only limited responses “fitting” to a particular comment and I notoriously see certain off-vibe when someone responds with a comment that doesn’t fit.
As if they didn’t see that their response feels grating because it doesn’t really fit properly
Tell me this, what do you understand from this:
- fuck trump
- fuck trump
It looks the same right? And now:
- fuck trump!
- FuCk TrUmP
Somepeople will read this and understand that the first is an insult towards trump, and the second is sarcasm that might be making fun of trump haters.
Text lacks the complexity of vocal speech, no volume, no pitch, no pauses or tonal changes, nothing. We can mitigate it by using different tools such as the upper and lpwer case in unconventional ways, we can use fonts and bold and color and emoji, etc. But this demends effort, sometimes more effort than the actual writing, so people don’t do it.
OP, you suck and you are an idiot.
Was I sarcastic?
Yes, I have nothing against you.
Context is everything.
No, I haven’t noticed it
No, I can’t say I’ve regularly seen that as a problem, at least not any moreso than other online spaces.
Communication is a two-way street. If one person fails to understand what you’re trying to say, that may be their fault. But if nobody seems to understand what you’re trying to say, if this is happening to you regularly enough that you have to ask this kind of question, maybe you’re not being clear enough.
As others have pointed out, text cannot carry tone, facial expressions, or other nuances that can picked up on with in-person conversations. When communicating through text, it’s important to keep that in mind and work within the limitations of text in order to be clear. Communicating effectively is a skill that takes effort to improve at.
Full disclosure that I do not know you and I don’t want to accuse you of anything, but this sounds like the kind of question that has a story behind it. If you do feel like this is a frequent problem for you, I think you should try to look inward.
It’s not about me by the way, it is from the perspective of a spectator, a lurker and not about me receiving some kind of response.
I don’t have anything against clarifications and back and forth and I don’t judge anyone
What is the goal of this post is to find people who can relate to my experience of just browsing spez site or more so, lemmy.
I don’t like to be alone in certain things and lemme tell you a lot of you feel very unintuitive to me.
As always with the exception of ADHD communities which every single member feels like I knew them for years no matter which site.As always with the exception of ADHD communities which every single member feels like I knew them for years no matter which site.
I think that the ADHD community takes things that other posters say at their word instead of making a bunch of assumptions. That is my general experience as someone with ADHD, things in a conversation are being said in good faith unless there is an obvious contradiction. Many conversations with neurotypical people feel like I’m participating in a conversation where the other person’s past experiences are being projected on to me instead of listening to what I’m saying.
One wonders how much of this is down to the proportion of people on here for whom English is not their first language. I know that I struggle enough to comprehend any other languages which aren’t my native one to begin with (i.e. English, in my case) so a lot of subtlety surely flies over my head in those. Can’t imagine that situation is much different for others.
sometimes people will fall for obvious sarcasm, yeah
but it’s important to remember just how much of an echo chamber of jokes Lemmy/reddit/online as a whole are. Most people (Gen z too) don’t even know the loss meme.Also politics are at the point where the current president can literally blurt out “they’re eating the cats and dogs!!1!1!1” and people will believe it, so political irony is very much difficult to pull off successfully because the lines between !theonion@midwest.social and !nottheonion@lemmy.world are very thin.
As a rule of thumb, if I think the average TikTok watcher would get confused id add a /s, even if I have my disagreements about /s as a whole.
It’s not a Lemmy thing, it’s an Internet thing.
Truth be told, irony, sarcasm and nuance, are quite hard to do in a text format without being explicit. Hell, that’s the main reason emojis exist, to replace the facial gestures and tone of voice we use to cue each other in on subtle aspects of language like sarcasm.
Sarcasm online can be harder to pick up on, but there’s also a good chance many are on the spectrum.
Sarcasm is, like, totally for losers.
They do say it is the lowest form of wit.
/s
I disagree. I looove sarcasm
Take a look at these guys!














