Dungeon Crawler Carl was full of misogyny, racism, and ableism. There is a great full review here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/7548962785
Disclaimer, I did not write the review, I just agree with it.
EDIT
This comment has a pastebin link to the review in it’s entirety.
Thank you Seb the goblin.
Judging by a short web search, it looks like he claims to try to subtly deliver left-wing political thought to rightwing readers. If true, the “misogyny, racism, and ableism” might be chosen deliberately to obscure an overarching narrative that’s essentially left-wing. But I haven’t read the books or the review (definitely not going to sign into a site to read a book review), so I have no idea what the alleged -isms look like.
Also, the author’s name is Matt, not Carl.
As someone who’s read the books, the main character deliberately identifies any toxic thoughts and corrects for them, acknowledging them being bad and not what he wants to foster within himself. The racist/etc caricatures are created by the system and his entire purpose is to point out how fucked up and wrong they are to the point of rallying others to help take them down.
Calling dungeon crawler carl a racist series is akin to calling the color purple racist. Pointing out the problems of the racism is the point. Same with all the other isms. The show runners are literally race purists who think all other species and groups are lesser, using brainwashing and torture to correct members of their species who go against this perceived purity. These are made very clear to be the bad guys. The series is straight up saying this is not ok.
Can you screenshot that review? I can’t read it without signing in and I’m unwilling to create an account.
Dusted off an old account I haven’t used for years for this: https://paste.trom.tf/igiwodejap.rust (was too long for comment, so had to put in a pastebin)
Okay, a lot of that is just bullshit. For instance, the stuff about some of the mobs being caricatures/stereotypes. A whole hunk of the story is that aliens have designed the dungeon to represent earth cultures, but they’ve done it based on grotesque negative stereotypes in order to make humans look bad to the other alien races. It’s clear that this is supposed to be bad and hurtful, and it paints racism as a bad thing. The books aren’t very deep, but apparently the author isn’t able to get even that.
It’s one thing for the aliens to play on negative Earth stereotypes (the commentary I was expecting and looking for), and it’s another thing when the POV characters do. It’s Carl’s first person POV depicting the people and events using that language, not the aliens’. And it’s Princess Donut telling him to kill because she’s “disgusting.” He wants to help/team up with her, but the sarcasm of “Yeah, that’ll be a no” is basically the entire argument it takes for him to do a murder instead.
Because if the author originally intended this to be about how horrible the aliens are, then the MC shouldn’t be the one thinking these horrible things. Full stop. But the author is the one who chose to do a first person narrative. He failed to describe people in a way that doesn’t put the words and feelings in his MC’s head.
It’s Carl’s first person POV depicting the people and events using that language, not the aliens’.
He literally describes it as a stereotype. He gets angry about the depictions.
And it’s Princess Donut telling him to kill because she’s “disgusting.”
And she’s supposed to be a pampered show cat who is somewhat shallow and judgemental. We’re not supposed to think those views are good.


