Can someone explain to me how my state got everything else right for the most part but went stupid for this one?
Literally, let’s inspect little girls privates, but not boys, because 10 trans students exist and MIGHT want to play sports with their friends? Jesus.
It was also kind of disgusting that literally all our state initiatives were funded by a 1%-er, Brian Heywood and his Let’s Go Washingtion PAC.
All male sports athletes should just play with their dicks out. Only way to be sure.
Pass legislation and call it the Humans Actually Requiring Athletic Male Body Exhibition law.
That’s how swimming used to be back in the 50s. Kinda fucked up how adamant parents were to keep it that way at the time.
Fix the timeline…
Pretty sure a lot of republicans would vote for that…
Just like in Ancient Greece, who were famously vehement anti-pedophiles.
The measure says students in elementary, middle and high school who want to join girls’ athletics must first submit statements from their healthcare providers verifying their “biological sex”. Opponents have raised alarms the measure may force girls to endure “invasive and extreme” genital exams to participate in school sports.
Can the state supreme court block it?
What the fuck.
And specifically targeting girls. How the fuck does something like this even get on the ballot?
Brian Heywood, a republican millionaire who moved to WA from California to “escape liberals”, has been abusing the ballot initiative system here using his wealth for years. He (and his PAC “Let’s Go Washington”) purposefully makes them misleading or otherwise confusing to understand in order to get them passed.
A silver lining is that most of his initiatives haven’t passed (such as the initiative to repeal the millionaire tax), and those few that have over the years have been gutted, heavily modified, or found to be unconstitutional in the state supreme court. The supreme court here just became even more left leaning, and since the way he wrote the initiative makes it only apply to girls, it’s likely to be thrown out.
Thankfully it’s got a good shot at being ruled unconstitutional, assuming the supreme court doesn’t fuck that up too.
That is just humiliating. These aren’t professional sports leagues for god’s sake.
The measure “may” force girls to endure invasive and extreme genital exams? I’m pretty sure having one’s genitals examined, especially when a minor, is invasive and extreme.
Epstein is getting hard in is grave
Will I don’t support the ban. This seems a little over the top. Invasive and extreme? Any kid getiing regual exams yearly by their doctor get a genital check. That is enough I am sure. Where it gets complicated is with the poor, who can’t afford to have a regular pediatrician. But sadly they usually can’t afford to play school sports often. So there are a ton of problems with all this, like a ton. But I don’t think there are going to be any invasive and extreme exams as a result. With all the real problems this creates, can’t we just stick to those?
My kid didn’t, I was told vaginal exams only start when they become sexually active.
Vaginal exam is more than is needed to confirm boy vs girl. The docs always just lifted the underwear and looked for any sign of abnormalities that might need treatment. No poking or touching even needed.
I don’t remember getting my genitals looked at in regular exams when I was young. Regardless of that, these are NOT health exams–they are to inspect the genitals of the child. That is extreme as fuck. These genital inspections are discriminatory, as boys do not have to submit to them. How anyone could accept this, let alone vote for it, is absolutely insane.
They aren’t requiring a specific exam. They are just requiring a doctor to sign off that they are biologically a boy or girl. This basically come down to lifting the underwear and looking down, which is what is normally done at an early are to check for abnormalities that may need to be addressed. No touching even need to take place. At a very young age, like pre 1 or so, they do a bit more detailed checking for issues. So if you have the same doc, they could sign off based on that alone.
I wonder if they’re required to satisfy the federal standard for sex identification. That would require more than a genital exam. It would require capturing a zygote.
Pretty invasive.
It would require capturing a zygote.
Did you mean capturing a gamete? As in, a viable sperm cell or egg? Which proves that the individual is biologically capable of producing those gametes, which means they are capable of producing viable offspring?
Because capturing a zygote (a viable egg that has been successfully fertilized by a viable sperm cell, but hasn’t yet implanted itself on the uterine wall to become an embryo) would require a woman to have a fertilized egg. And I feel like requiring impregnation just to confirm sex is a little… Impractical?
It would mean positively identifying males would be impossible, because they’re not capable of carrying a zygote at all. That that’s before we even get into the whole “in order to confirm an elementary school girl is biologically female so she can compete, the doctor would first need to impregnate her to create a zygote” thing.
I did indeed mean gamete, and thank you for the correction.
Super disappointed and the ballot guides argument for and against focused on very stupid points and not on anything to do with facts about transwomen and girls, not highlighted the discrepancies of greeting girls and women different from boys and men.
I don’t want to take away from your point, but I do want to point out that “trans women and girls” is probably a better written version of the same phonetic statement simply because trans is being used an adjective like “brilliant” or “gorgeous” or “empowered”
We won the war but lost the battle… Also this is sure to get sued and challenged as it’s a direct discrimination based on sex and title IX prohibits that shit
The State Constitution also prohibits this. It will hopefully never take effect because a state court must shut this down.
It wouldn’t be the first right-wing ballot initiative to go directly into the trash in this state.
The war is ongoing make no mistake.
😢
GO BLUE WAVE
Read the room, my dude
What, that ya don’t like being told that blue wave has blood in it? Sorrry. Don’t care.
You can’t even get a street name changed in America without paying the pedos. You think the Democrats are going to do anything without cracking a few legs?
They’ve got the American people on the boat. There is no land in sight.
Deleted by moderator
This dumb bullshit better get overturned ffs
Kind of weird how people claim to love democracy but want to overturn the will of its voters when its something they disagree with.
Funny enough this one passing really goes to show how stupid most voters seem to be in WA now.
They literally want to overturn one law they voted for years ago and they want to have a state supreme court who have all agreed that the incoming millionaire tax can go ahead even if it breaks the states constitution.
The state Dems need some real DSA competition because at this point it’s all pointing towards corporatacy with a veiled control of an oligarchy.
I would ask our WA incumbents to reveal their minutes behind closed doors with lobbyists and full financial disclosures to be reviewed by a non political backed watchdog but the very same court we just voted in said “go pound cold wet sand”
Nah its not weird to want to overturn stupid harmful bullshit built on bigoted misinformation.
Democracy isn’t JUST voting for things and dealing with it. It’s the entire process within which there are mechanisms to overturn dumb illegal bullshit. Bullshit like subjecting young girls to molestation to soothe nazi hysteria.
Agreed with more DSA reps though no argument there.
Hey it’s the guy that voted Yes on repealing the millionaires tax in Washington. I wonder what other initiatives from Brian Heywood you voted Yes on. Maybe this one?
Going against a misleading discriminatory bill is not “going against the will of the people”. It’s funny that you’d say that, and in the same breath complain about the millionaire’s tax that you voted to repeal failing.
A bit of humor for the time: https://theneedling.com/2026/11/05/girls-finally-safe-now-that-they-have-to-show-adult-their-vagina-to-play-school-sports/
Also fuck Brian Heywood!
If you get an explanation, let me know. I’m dumbfounded by this one.
Nearly every other thing I voted on went the way I expected/voted, off the top of my head the only ones that didn’t were a state supreme court race and a local city election.
How did we get the other two state initiatives right but this one wrong??
Wow I thought Washington was inclusive
Depends on which side of the mountains
If you look at the map, pretty much the whole state outside of Seattle metro voted for it :(
I don’t like it, but I can get how it passed. Some league called the cops on a three year old becuase he was too good and the parents of the other kids wanted him gone. People feel strongly about fair play. And so they are susceptible to the propaganda. The “problem” is total BS, but it plays on a common emotion not matter your party affiliation.
All in all. There is very little balance in school sports anyway. Team sports especially. In those, the school with more money usually finds a way to win. So even if someone feels it isn’t fair to have a transgirl compete with women… there are much bigger sources of unfairness out there. But this one feels like something they can do something about. So again the propoganda ends up working. :(
This is sexist and transphobic
Could you clarify? Cause what I wrote was understanding how a bill managed to pass, and how it’s propaganda managed to work. So what specifically are you referring to when you say “this”. If it is the entire comment, you should read it again and spend a moment to think about it before communicating a knee jerk reaction.
Just change “transgirl” to “trans girl”, and “women” to “cis girl”, and you’re mostly good.
The language of oppression creeps into our speech, even when we don’t mean for it to. The way you phrased it at the end carries meaning of “trans girls aren’t real girls and real girls are better”, since you gave trans girls a different noun and gave cis girls the title of (real)women.
Then you said “there are much bigger sources of unfairness out there”, implying that to have a trans person on a cis team is unfair. The science says there is no unfairness.
I certainly wouldn’t have called the whole post transphobic, and I wouldn’t even be commenting this if I thought you actually were. But, since you seen to be genuinely interested in being an ally. There ya go.
Thanks that is helpful. I struggle with the right labels. I used cis on some other post comment and got bullied hard because I didn’t use it right. I’m trying to learn. I certainly am intending to try and be an ally. But I also have a massive dislike for propaganda. Which was really the target on my comment. Hoping that people would direct their hate at those who would use propaganda and psychology to trick well meaning people into supporting bad legislation rather than those that fell for it.
As for advantage. I think that gets complicated. From what I have read, the length of time on puberty blockers and gender affirming hormones is relevant to equalizing the physical advantage. And those aren’t required to identify as trans. So a trans women “could” have significant advantages. Especially in the school years. My kid runs in a circle with a lot of LGTBQ+ kids. And most of the trans ones don’t have their parent’s support. So they aren’t on any special medications. They also don’t happen to have any interest in sports though. But I also know the doctors tend to shy away from gender affirming hormones until 16.
So I think the advantage “can” be there. And specifically under 16, it could be a decent percent who didn’t get the support they should have when younger. That said, I generally don’t think the advantage in those age brackets is any more than kids who just physically mature early. But I don’t like to say there is there is no advantage. But that goes back to my dislike of propoganda, which is really based on a bit of an obsession with accuracy of statements. That said. I can see how my words there could be interpreted as supporting the propoganda that the advantage is significant and common. So I will try to do better.You’re doing great.
And yes, you’re right about an advantage if the person wants to play female sports and isn’t estrogen dominant. I’m sorry I didn’t specify. The science says:
No one who has their current testosterone levels above cis female levels should be allowed to play in the women’s league. Full stop. This should apply to anyone playing in any sport after puberty begins. Even a cis woman would have a huge advantage with increased testosterone levels.
Anyone who has had testosterone and estrogen at cis female levels for 2 years, should be allowed to play in any women’s league. They have no advantage no matter how long they lived otherwise.
Sex based segregation for sports is in reality hormone based segregation. Which makes sense because hormones do dramatically affect performance. We should just call them like they are, adjust our criteria based on scientific fact, and move on with our lives.
Idgaf even if you call yourself a man and want to play with the women. If you meet the hormonal criteria (estrogen and testosterone at cis female levels for two years prior to, and the entire time you play) go ahead.
I would include even no contact sports like chess or darts. Hormones effect everything.
This just adds another barrier and pathway to abuse to women’s sports
Transphobia comes from misogyny, they want to hurt both the cis girls and the trans girls.
That’s the point! Brian Heywood wants girls and women to avoid playing sports.
Congrats you have banned 1% of children from a leisure activity and now require minors to present their genitals to adults of no relation.
1% is a huge overstatement. There’s like 4 in the whole state.
4 trans minors in the entire state? I am doubtful.
if you actually think its a whole 1% then you should probably think about it a bit more.
I love cis people telling me this shit
im not sure what that is supposed to mean, or what relevance that even has to this topic, but you’re welcome i guess.
Can someone explain to me how my state got everything else right for the most part but went stupid for this one?
If that’s an actual question, my guess at an answer is that since this election’s blue wave was more voting against Republicans than for Democrats, it’s not a sign of fundamental change among the electorate. People mostly still believe today what they believed a few years ago (though there’s clear leftward shift), and one of the few genuinely popular things Republicans have is their anti-trans agenda. Therefore when typically Republican-leaning people got to vote on it, they voted against Republicans and simultaneously against trans rights. This is doubly so because trans women in sports is one issue where Republicans can actually make a seemingly rational (but wrong) argument for their case.
Some things lag in politics. Trans kids in sports are the new boogeyman so most people have a hard time accepting the premise. If trans kids are going to be excluded we at least need to focus on education and general acceptance. When I was in high school pretty much nobody was openly gay although I like to think we wouldn’t have treated them like lepers (probably would have). Meeting LGBTQ people in college was common though and a lot of us got over our fears and misconceptions. I’ve met maybe 3-4 trans people in my entire life but in actuality it was probably more because they didn’t feel safe to present as the opposite gender. Unfortunately I think it will take time to get over the initial shock and the best we can do is to try and defend their right to self-determination and encourage them to be who they are so everyone can see this is really no big deal.
Also from a purely propaganda point it’s a great wedge issue, mostly because it’s what I like to call a grey water issue wherein theres a lot of nuance involved so it makes people stupid. Ideally people would stop being stupid and handle this based on an instance by instance basis especially since there are so few trans folks to begin with.
Mind you I know enough about biology to know that it’s a rainbow of fucken grey, because biology abhors easy answers. There’s no such thing as a perfect specimen only a type specimen and even that’s ignoring a lot of variation.
Serious question: does this explicitly say that the person whose job it is to inspect the genitals of girls cannot touch the girls?
If not, there’s almost certainly going to be a pedo in this position taking advantage of this new rule to touch underage girls’ genitalia
The article says statement from their healthcare provider, so they should be subject to the Hippocratic oath.
Ain’t nobody got deductible money round here! This is going to quickly turn into the pedoiest doctor around setting up shop in the gym a few times a year, with a perfectly legal “show a little pussy for play” stand where all the girls flash gash for a sticker and a lollipop.
He’ll probably get away with “needing more than a glance” too. As I’m sure “woman” is defined in such a way as to require more than labia.
History shows that to be very optional















