What happened?
So 2 days ago I was getting back on my family desktop, but I noticed that Windows was slow, like VERY slow. I hear the hardware making decently loud noises all the time
Ok, then it’s a great opportunity to switch to Linux!
No! You see, it’s a family desktop and it’s been there for 10+ years, which means if I install another operating system, 10 years of familiarity will be vanished! Even if I choose a distro with a Windows-like UI, the apps supported there aren’t garenteed to be recognized by my parents! Maybe they could tolerate Firefox and mayyyybe Ungoogled Chromium, but that’s about it
Ok, did you asked your parents?
I told them I thought about it. My mom doesn’t use it for personal stuff at all and my dsd uses it for YouTube, word, excel, etc, so nothing too crazy. OnlyOffice (and LibreOffice from what I heard of) does support Microsoft’s file types. I asked them if they could toleratebthe alternative software. My dad said he would think about it. Currently, he said that we don’t have a USB with big enough storage space to fit all the data in to backup and restore on the new OS. But my parents are surprisngly open when it comes to my personal discsions. So, hope isn’t yet lost
Conclusion and solutions
It’s a gray area for now. Idk if my parents could tolerate Linux Mint, but if they could, that’s a massive win. If I could figure out how to dual-boot, then it’s a possible middle ground. Another possible middle ground is running Windows within Virtual Box for my parents. Best case scenario: The open-source alternatives are good enough for my parents’ use cases
Lemmy know about your opinions down in the comments
Let them get used to FOSS programs before changing the whole system.
Good selection here
–
Also, you can run Linux for yourself by installing Qemu on windows, and then run Linux inside that, as a virtual machine.
Apps first, then the OS. Let them try and learn Libre office (or what ever) and Firefox first. Once they feel okay with it (and can fall back if needed) THEN reload the OS after a good backup.
Edit: as a bonus, when you do switch them over, it will suddenly feel fast for them. That’s the hook. ;). 🍪
If you really want to do this, first install the windows version of the applications. THAT is the big hurdle, not the OS.
Don’t switch to Linux. Based off your replies to other comments it will only frustrate you and your family.
Here’s the nutshell, along with extended info in spoilers:
Your computer is broken; you may be at risk of losing data, and Linux won’t fix it.
The speed plus the noise sounds like either CPU fan failure or hard drive failure. CPU fans are cheap to replace; hard drives aren’t right now.
Thus, if it’s not the CPU fan, it’s probably not worth blowing a bunch of money on an aging computer to replace parts when other things will probably break; also, back up that computer ASAP.
10+ years is a long time to use a computer, and it’s great that you were resourceful and kept using that thing instead of being wasteful, but you will thank yourself for just getting a new computer.
If you’re on a constrained budget, you could probably get a computer from five or so years ago so long as it has enough RAM.
“Good” Microsoft Office compatibility often isn’t enough, especially when it comes to Excel macros.
Even if your dad doesn’t use macros, maybe he depends on collaborative editing features with a Microsoft account (although this can be done with Office Web).
Your dad might be so used to Office, he doesn’t even realize what features he uses, and the only to know is to watch him dk his work, which might be annoying.
Also, if you’re dad’s using this for professional work with a broader organization or company, he probably can’t afford to have anything less than perfect MS Office compatibility.
I will say, OnlyOffice/EuroOffice actually seems to do a pretty good job with format compatibility (LibreOffice not so much), but my points still stand.
Don’t turn your family into guinea pigs.
No matter how well you think you or they are prepared, they’re ultimately getting turned into an experiment here; you don’t want this.
On one level, you probably don’t want to accidentally hurt or annoy your family by causing data loss or hurting productivity when you’re not around to fix problems.
On another, you’ll be responsible for anything that goes wrong, and you really don’t want to be in that position no matter how good you are, for the sake of your relationship with your family and own sanity.
Also, drive partitioning, while not necessarily hard, is easy to mess up; I’m relatively experienced and have still messed up a few times, sometimes to disastrous or at least annoying consequences.
I love Linux, but people have to want it; you shouldn’t go evangelizing for it, especially if it means pushing it on your family.
Keep going in your Linux journey, but find somewhere safe to do it.
I personally learned Linux by tinkering with it in a VM for several years before deciding to daily-drive it. Pretty much anything made since about 2010 should be able to run a Linux VM pretty okay, as long as it has enough RAM and storage.
Also please wait until you have your own computer to try Linux outside a VM; you could probably find a pretty cheap used laptop that would do the trick.
Idk what are macros bruh
Basically, sometimes someone needs to add another function to Excel, so they write a program in a language called Visual Basic that extends Excel.
Your dad might be using macros and not even realizing it; they’re sometimes embedded in spreadsheets, or his organization may have given him instructions to install them many years ago that he doesn’t remember. He probably expects things to just work, and these very much won’t on anything except Windows since Visual Basic is only on Windows.
The only way to know is check every Excel setting and spreadsheet, and even then, if he’s doing serious work on the computer, who’s to say work won’t give him a task that requires them in the future?
The artcraft suite does a remarkably good job of recreating the main MS office programs. The UI looks almost exactly the same.
Combine this with a KDE theme that makes it look similar to windows and you should be good to go
Besides my ideological qualms with this, OP has no idea if his dad uses VBA macros.
Also, if his dad’s using it for serious work, he probably can’t afford to have anything less than perfect MS Office compatibility to sanely interoperate with the rest of the organization, especially if he’s using MS collaboration features.
Idk what are macros bruh
i hear KDE can get pixel to pixel indistinguishable from windows 10 if you install the proper themes and scripts.
Currently running Win 11, not Win 10
@MisterFred@reddthat.com , sorry for the @ but your thread is blowing up with either unparsibly long replies or people giving you bad advice.
You do not know enough about Linux to do what you’re asking about. You need to know enough in order to handle any problems that come up and you’re just not there yet. Maybe if you didn’t possibly have a dying pc then you could try it.
On the subject of your dying family pc: go control panel > system (or right click the start menu and select “system”.) A window showing a bunch of information about your computer will pop up. Scroll down a little bit to make sure it’s all on screen then take a picture with your phone and post it in reply to my comment.
You could also just copy it all down by hand but a pictures quicker.
Listen to this post. It’s right.
- What is making noise on this PC? It could be a hard drive, which could mean it’s failure and data loss is imminent. I would check drive health percentage with crystaldiskinfo: https://crystalmark.info/en/download/#CrystalDiskInfo
And even if the health on that drive is ok, 10 years is very old for hard drives, and it could fail at any time. One of the drives in my computer is about that old, and I only trust it with steam games that have cloud saves in case it craps out. You (and your parents) should not trust it to store important stuff long term. Back up important documents ASAP!
If you determine the hard drive isn’t making the noise, another cause could be old cooling fans clogged with dust. Cleaning them should help (NO VACUUMS! use antistatic brushes and canned air/antistatic electric air blowers. Also, don’t let the fans spin when blowing air on them. They can break if you do this). Sometimes fan bearings wear out and they make noise even after cleaning. Replacement of the fan itself is required in that case. You might need to order fans specific to that desktop if the fan header is proprietary (unfortunately common on prebuilt desktops).
- Let’s address the slowness, which on a computer this old likely has multiple causes.
Honestly, the main cause of slowness is probably not Windows as much as it is a mechanical hard drive being used as a boot drive (my guess given the computer’s age). This was super common a decade ago due to cost reasons, but slow storage is a huge performance bottleneck for modern operating systems, even Linux. I’ve installed Linux on systems with mechanical hard drives, and they were still super slow before swapping the hard drive out for an SSD. Once I did that, it felt like a completely different computer!
Unfortunately, due to AI crap, SSDs are super pricy now. I think your best bet is getting the cheapest low capacity SSD (currently this one on pcpartpicker: https://pcpartpicker.com/product/tWcG3C/patriot-burst-elite-120-gb-25-solid-state-drive-pbe120gs25ssdr ) installing the OS onto that, and using a hard drive (ideally a newer, more reliable one) for bulk storage.
Another hardware issue that could make that computer slow is thermal throttling (getting too hot). You can check whether the CPU is getting too hot with Core Temp: https://www.alcpu.com/CoreTemp/ The CPU ideally should be ~75°C while CPU load is at 100%.
There are two things that cause thermal throttling: dust, and dry thermal paste. Cleaning dust off of fans and the CPU cooler fins helps with the dust.
If cleaning doesn’t alleviate the thermal throttling, you might need to replace thermal paste. In between the CPU cooler and the CPU, PC makers apply thermal paste to make heat transfer more effectively from the CPU to the cooler. Over time, it dries out and stops working as well as it should. I like to clean it off and replace it with Arctic MX 6: https://www.arctic.de/us/MX-6/ACTCP00079A
To replace thermal paste, you need to remove the cooler and clean it and the CPU with rubbing alcohol and q tips to remove the old paste. Then, apply a pea sized glob (or an x) of new thermal paste on the CPU and squish the cooler on top. Tighten the screws on the cooler in a cross pattern for even pressure when fastening, unless it’s an Intel stock cooler with the plastic clips, where you fasten a diagonal first and then the other diagonal.
- Let’s say you fix up the PC (new SSD, dusted out, thermal paste replacement, fan replacement, whatever it ends up needing). There is still the question of whether Linux will be a good fit for what your parents need out of this computer.
Before you go and install Linux, make sure the software available over there is appropriate for your parents’ needs. You can do this by installing cross platform software that works on both Windows and Linux, and letting your parents try it while still on Windows.
In my experience with Libreoffice, simple documents feel easier to make than Microsoft’s suite. Unfortunately, if he uses documents other people make, the compatibility with Microsoft formats is a bit iffy for anything but the simplest documents. This makes collaboration with other people using the Microsoft suite very frustrating. If he’s making simple documents in word and excel, and he doesn’t need to collaborate with others or use it for work, Libreoffice might work well for him. Otherwise, it just isn’t ready yet, and you may need to spin up a VM, wine/bottles (wip), or dual boot when switching to Linux.
“Decent amount of noise all the time” is more likely to mean dusty fans as even amateurs tend to describe hard drive clicking accurately.
Resolve the hardware issues before you introduce more changes.
Dual boot
Telling a new user to play with a partitions is like telling a child to play with a chain saw.
Heck, I’ve been using Linux for years and still bungled it up on occasion.
It’s a learning opportunity 😄
Dual boot doesn’t solve the issue, if you want get rid of Windows. Now you have half way out, still have to manage and use Windows, while also learning something new. Dual boot is one of the worst experiences, especially for people who are not very versed in computing. Its better to switch completely off Windows, or stay on Windows for the best experience.
Back up the data without letting anyone know.
Eventually the computer will fail. By then, just replace it with one with an alternative system already installed. If anyone doesn’t feel happy about it, let them provide another solution.
People are hard to work with.
Don’t persuade. Let them fail miserably.
People are too damn dumb and beyond saving. Let them crawl to you.
Or just don’t bother.
This is incredibly cynical advice.
There’s a hair of truth in here, in the sense that people often don’t know what is best for them outside their area of expertise, and you may need to act decisively to make sure their best interests are served, sometimes regardless of their feelings.
However, just because you know better than someone doesn’t mean you know better enough to know what’s best for them.
Deciding whether you know better enough is sometimes a personal judgement, but here I know that OP knows better enough, but not enough to make this decision for the whole family.
For instance, I remember a time when I decided I knew better and accidentally took down the family Wi-Fi trying to set up a “better” DNS server.
Back up the data without letting anyone know.
Don’t persuade. Let them fail miserably.
Bad advice.
Care to elaborate? Care to venture a alternative suggestion?
Is “letting Microsoft put up their bullshit, and me taking all the technical debt of maintenance, while everybody suffers from performance, just that you can still look at the UI which is familiar to you” a good one then?
The problem then comes down to convincing and as we all know, people can’t be convinced. There needs to be “social engineering”.
I don’t like letting people fail with the intention to fail them. That is bad experience we try to avoid. Instead doing backups without their knowledge, which only makes them more not care because you babysit and did everything for them. I also don’t like handling data without their consent and knowledge. We should explain, train and show them what to do, and why.
people can’t be convinced
What do you mean people can’t be convinced? Off course they can be. Some may not, but that is not the rule, that is the exception. And not everyone is able to pull it off.
First things first, I’d but a new harddrive. You will want backups either way, it will give you space to run both Windows and Linux, but most importantly, sudden loud noises could mean your harddrive is about to crash, in which case you will lose everything anyway.
If you’ve got an old spinning harddrive, upgrading to an SSD is going to make your PC faster even if you don’t move to Linux. Although for 10 year old hardware, I’d definitely prefer Linux over the increasing bloat of Windows.
And while you’re getting the new ssd, also get a usb stick. They cost almost nothing. (SSDs, unfortunately, have gotten more expensive since last year.)
Mostly good advice, but I don’t think it’s worth it to upgrade a 10 year old computer anymore due to SSD prices, especially when OP’s parents probably just need a working computer.
Don’t get me wrong, I love continuing to use old hardware; when I failed to repair my younger sibling’s laptop, I loaned them a 10 year-old laptop running Debian, and it got them by. However, I just don’t think it’s worth it here.
- Copy your family’s unique files (docs etc) onto a flash or portable drive, or cloud storage.
- Open computer. Remove your existing windows HDD and keep it safe.
- Fit an ssd drive in its place, 120G should be fine, they’re still cheap. Install your linux distro of choice. Copy over the docs from storage.
Then, you know you have a full path back to where you started if you get shouted at. Just swap the drives over and you’re back in slow windows land.
Yes, running windows in a vm on a linux host works fine, as does dual-booting, although the latter runs a risk of making full recovery impossible if it goes wrong. Yes, running normal desktop stuff like Office apps and web browsing is pretty much identical, and non-technical users adapt pretty quickly to most linux window managers, IME
A 10yo computer may have a mechanical hdd which will be slow whatever OS you use, but unless you’ve kept up with Windows updates, it’ll also be very unsafe to be using online. That may be the reason why it’s suddenly running slowly - it’s got malware. Installing a new OS would solve that too.
Just install Linux and tell em “Hey, Windows got a massive update last week and it’s now 100 times faster!” and leave it at that.
Normally I’d find this funny, but this is the wrong situation for this joke. Phrases like “mom”, “dad”, and “family computer” suggest this is a kid (no offense OP) with little knowledge who might just do this.
Literally did that to my mom in law. Changed the firefox icon to the internet exploder icon, installed a Windows 7 theme.
She only noticed after 6 months.







