Can someone explain why there are so many stories of bad HOAs in America? Don’t everyone in the HOA get to vote on who will be on the board and what rules there should be? Why do many of them seem to have strange and petty rules? What makes them able to issue fines for so small infractions? Where does the fine money go? Who sets up the HOA in the first place and what is the motivation to do so?
We got plenty of similar associations where I live (both for apartments and houses, though not so often for fully detached homes) and they usually work great. Basically you pay a monthly fee to your HOA that the board use to keep the plumbing and outside areas maintained, pay for tv/internet for everyone at a much reduced cost or maintain other common areas like laundry rooms, guest apartment, parking garage, workshop etc. There are of course some restrictions too you need to follow, but those are usually minor and common sense anyways (like you shouldn’t play very loud music too late in an apartment in the middle of the week) and that you don’t get to do whatever you want to the outside of your place.
(Another common rule is that you need HOA approval to sublet your apartment. This can be occasionally annoying to deal with, but is good because it prevents people from buying up apartments just to rent them out. And most of the time the HOA will approve you if you’re just moving away for a year or similar.)




They can, and I think it makes a lot of sense.
Lets say you start a lawncare business and buy a lawnmower for $1000. You don’t manage to get that many customers the first year, and only make exactly $1000. You haven’t lost money, but didn’t make any profit either.
Should you now have to pay tax on those $1000 dollars of revenue, causing you to have lost money despite your hard work? Where would you even get that money from to pay the tax?
I think the problem is not the basic system, but that the rules are too complex and have loopholes that allow you to pay less tax if you are an expert on the rules - or have enough money that it’s worth it to hire one.