knightly the Sneptaur

  • 21 Posts
  • 529 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2023

help-circle
  • Ah yes, let’s make sport less accessible by introducing arbitrary limitations.

    Where did I suggest that? Are you sure you aren’t hallucinating?

    Do we have basketball up to 1.60m height, then up to 1.70m height, then up to 1.80m height and so on? And do we introduce different tiers within those tiers by only having people up to 1.70m and 60kg, then 1.70 and 70kg …

    I said “performance classes” not “height and weight classes”.

    You CANT split sport into “performance classes”, at least not in a way where it would help - men would on average still be in the higher “performance class” and nothing would change.

    Why not? Explain your reasoning for why women wouldn’t perform to roughly the same level as everyone else in their performance class. Bonus points if you can manage to avoid sexism in your explanation.

    I know you probably don’t want to hear that, but biologically, trans women aren’t women.

    I know you probably don’t want to hear this, but the biological differences between cis and trans people are irrelevant. Sports were only segregated because men’s precious feelings get hurt when they are bested by women. Forcing trans women to compete against men will cause men to lose to people they don’t recognize as men and thereby create more problems than were solved.

    Nobody has a problem with trans women in non-physical sports. Nobody would bat an eye if there was a trans women in chess.

    Wow…

    You should have just admitted you have no idea what you’re talking about. Bans on trans women in chess have been a multi-year scandal for the International Chess Federation.

    Nobody would care if there was a trans woman in e-sports (we actually had one years ago in league if I remember correctly).

    When did they start segregating e-sports? Last I checked, the big tournaments were all mixed.

    But we can’t just abandon fairness for cis women in sport because we want to appease a small number of trans women, and on a physical level (especially before hormone therapy), they still do have an advantage.

    Because abandoning fairness to enforce gender testing that will primarily harm cis women by excluding them from competition for having too much natural testostetone like Caster Semenya is better, right?