I find this move concerning, and wish that the Founder had looked for a new CEO that shared his values rather than a Private Equity and Mergers Expert.
Furthermore, the change to the GRIT motto is worrying. Trust is useless without Transparency when it comes to code and security.
I just installed Bitwarden because 979 2FA started refusing to show my codes unless I set up a password and fingerprint (and fails when I try anyway). Now to find something else I guess.
Why does every good thing always have to go to shit. Sigh.
because capitalism
This
Edit: wrong comment section ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I have also been getting popup ads every time I login now. It started a few months ago. Annoying but I’m using their hosting service so I can’t really complain.
I have been giving them $20 per year because nothing is free
Same, I have the yearly subscription not because I use the features but because I want to support the project.
I’ll leave the subscription for now, but the second they start LastPassing things up I’m cancelling the subscription.
Also my start 9 has VaultWarden as an official app, I just haven’t seen the need to get it setup, now I do. I guess I know what I’m doing this weekend…
reading this as someone who migrated the rest of the household to Bitwarden literally yesterday: 😒
What do you use it for?
passwords and secure notes of recovery codes and the like
It took me years after the lastpass breach to get my wife and 1/3 of my kids to switch to Bitwarden. I am not looking to having to migrate again.
but exporting is easy with bitwarden. this is annoying. after the age check laws, i have been moving off big companies because it will be bad snd i know my migration will take a bit. i finalized bitwarden a couple weeks ago and was just about to assist my family.
i would not be as upset if ram and harddtives didnt cost a mortgage right now.
It does not matter how easy exporting is, the difficulty is going someone who really does not understand why they should be using a password locker to use one, much less change to a different one.
You won’t have to. Bitwarden is FOSS. The server is able to be self hosted so “migration” will just be you moving their account to the self hosted one if things go south
Does this mean other companies are hosting compatible servers to switch to?
I mean some may be offering that but it means you can just rent a cheap. VPS and host your own
Let the enshittification begin.
Looks like I’m moving over to something else now.
Was good while it lasted. Thanks for getting me off LastPass. See ya
Goddammit.
As long as they don’t enshittify the mobile apps and browser extensions, I’m neither surprised nor concerned. Vaultwarden exists.
And if they do ruin the client end, I expect third-party alternative clients, or a wholly new alternative, will appear soon enough.
(Yes, yes, “b-but KeePass!” folks… I’ve been there.)
As long as they don’t enshittify
lol you don’t know how this works yet
Its never an if, its a when. And that when is VERY soon.
I hate that I upvoted this, but it’s the frustrating truth
If you’re looking for alternatives and you don’t care about automatic device syncing, I have been enjoying using keepassxc
If you have a cloud storage provider, and you save your keepass database to it, then you also get automatic syncing for all devices that can connect to that cloud.
Sure, i’ll put my password db somewere I have zero control over, just for convenience
You would’ve already been doing that with BitWarden.
Pretty sure I don’t. I don’t have bitwarden.
Just keepass. On two pc’s and backup to my nas.
Isn’t the keepass db file encrypted?
Its like you have your own cloud storage provider.
One device on the lan … would not call that cloud.
It does a similar function though. Your devices are able to connect to it and sync a keepass db between the two. You have a solid solution IMO.
my nas.
Wow, talk about missing the point.
your nas is your cold storage provider
You can selfhost your cloud storage, for instance using Nextcloud, if you want to maintain complete control
Nextcloud, syncthing, sftp can all be self hosted
I’m the weirdo with the tin foil hat, but thats how I feel about ALL of these services. I don’t care how secure anyone says they are.
It’s incredibly inconvenient, but I have all my passwords saved as documents written in a cryptic and incomplete way so that only I know what they mean on my pc. It sucks that if I don’t remember one I have to wait until I get home, but I’ll never trust any of these services. EVERYTHING gets hacked eventually.
If you are happy with cloud services, please, go ahead. But not for me … True. I’m having close to zero trust however safe they say it is. My choice is to have my data on my hardware that i own and control and can access 24/7.
Ps: You can’t hack me, i carry around my stack of post-it’s on my skin and they have medic style hand written passwords /s
Not everyone can self-host
You made me think about this a little bit, why couldn’t someone self host?
They don’t own the network, or don’t even have a network to connect to. I probably vastly underestimate the people who do not control their internet connection, or simply use devices that are on cell networks.
There are quite a few people that have a phone and/or tablet, and no WiFi. Not many who would care about this situation, but still
You can sync between devices securely with syncthing.
That being said, the syncthing-fork devs are refusing to get certified with Google Play (which I support) so by the end of the year you’ll need a deGoogle’d phone
I know. Keepass is a stand alone app. It does not need hosting.
https://keepassxc.org/docs/KeePassXC_UserGuide#_storing_your_database
You can keep it on a USB too
Keepassxc DB has strong encryption.
I do care about automatic device syncing
Update: After publication, an employee on the Bitwarden subreddit said that “Always free” had been restored on its pricing page, calling it an “oversight” by the marketing team. The product page for Bitwarden’s personal password manager remains unchanged.
We’re sorry we got caught
deleted by creator
They got community checked and backtracked hard… I have always endorsed bitwarden but that is becoming worrisome. :(
Yeah, you know those marketing team people. They totally went out of their way to make more work for themselves to change it with I’m sure zero instructions from higher up to do so.
Getting hard to endorse anyone you don’t personally know at this point.
hope this does not fuck up my vaultwarden hosting.
Narrator: …but it did.
I’m amazed that vaultwarden has maintained such fantastic compatibility with bitwarden. …but all it takes is one api with an obfuscated “signed request” to bring it all down.
No?
I get that clients might break, but the web portal running inside vaultwarden isn’t gonna suddenly stop working.
Vaultwarden itself is self-contained. An API change won’t do anything to it.
Then it creates the opportunity (need) for an open sourced client, if that ever happens, I’m confident the community will come together and make one using the currently known API calls.
The current (at least android) client for bitwarden is already open source (GPL 3).
I wasn’t certain what the bitwarden clients were licensed under.
…but if they’re all GPL, then yeah - it’ll just get forked. Just like terraform vs opentufu. Just like MySQL vs MariaDB - it’s a tale as old as time (unfortunately).
Vaultwarden has a backend encrypted db and web server, with it’s own API. The bitwarden clients are currently opensource so there could be a fork for the browser extension, and desktop client. Unlike 1Password, there is a good opensource base.
Same
Anyone have any idea how this affects Vaultwarden, if at all?
I think the short answer is that it doesn’t. VaultWarden is currently open source, and no private equity organization can put the genie back in the bottle. If things get really bad then someone would likely fork the open source bits and maintain a pure open source version, in which case there would likely be a procedure to migrate existing VaultWarden installs to the purely open source successor. I don’t think VaultWarden users need to be overly concerned at this point.
I thought the same, just wanted some reassurance :))
It won’t stop them from trying though. Just look at what Bambu is doing.
The fork would have to be a browser integration as the bitwarden extensions and desktop apps are the bitwarden part. Vaultwarden as the backend self-hosted db and webapp is opensource.
Edit: bitwarden clients are not yet closed source
Seems like the clients are at least source-available? https://github.com/bitwarden/clients
For now… That’s what would be forked, thanks for the correction
Short-term, no change.
Medium- and long-term, Bitwarden could cut off access to their clients and go closed source.
Hopefully, Vaultwarden devs take advantage of the early warning and prepare contingencies for
ifwhen Bitwarden crosses the point of no return.Aren’t Bitwarden clients open-source?
Glad I didn’t let myself get talked into switching to Bitwarden from my boring KeepassXC setup…




















