Do they actually know how the technology works? They will have to scan everything inbound and outbound connections, basically managed devices.

Apple and Google have been given a three-month ultimatum to make it impossible for children to take, share or view nude images on their smartphones, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer said on Monday.

  • godsammitdam@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    Maybe hold the parents accountable. Betya then they’ll start caring about what their children are doing. Because yes, while there are adult perpetrators, there are also children themselves selling media they create on things like roblox servers. It’s a rabbit hole.

    Bonus: you don’t have to invalidate everyone’s right to fucking privacy.

    Extra credit: you can still tax the fuck out of these trillion dollar corporations that are ruining the world.

    • dogdeanafternoon@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      5 months ago

      I’m not sure if I agree with this take. To me, it is similar to saying we shouldn’t give kids free lunches, cause it’s the parents responsibility to feed their kid.

      Like yeah, parents should be feeding their kid. But it’s also unreasonable to think that every single parent is doing that. It’s just not realistic, so we should definitely be feeding kids when they aren’t getting it at home.

      On the same token, I don’t see anything wrong with trying to protect kids from talking with strangers, or getting sent explicit material, when their parents don’t know or care how to do it themselves.

      • cheers_queers@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        5 months ago

        then enforce child predator laws. or rape laws in general. thats a REAL rabbit hole that will disgust any normal person. the problem is that nobody wants to deal with the actual problem so they outsource it to privacy nightmares like what we are seeing now

        • dogdeanafternoon@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          5 months ago

          I don’t think it HAS to be a privacy nightmare. It’s possible for all of this to happen securely on device.

          That being said I do not trust most corporations to implement it securely.

      • godsammitdam@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        edit-2
        5 months ago

        The lunch analogy is too generic for the complexity here and I think it breaks down entirely given the innate assumption that a parent’s responsibility is only a parent’s responsibility, which isn’t true.

        Should the government provide free school lunches? Absolutely. That requires funding and legislative will. The government has a responsibility (well, theoretically) to protect and serve its people, including children and families. An overlap of responsibility if you will. Free school lunches does not infringe on anyone’s rights and instead betters communities, eases burden on struggling parents, and helps students perform and receive proper nutrition. And should a family or student wish to not receive a school lunch, they are free to opt out and bring their own. It doesn’t require scanning every student’s lunchbox or installing surveillance infrastructure in every kitchen. The intervention is proportionate to the problem.

        Starmer’s proposal isn’t. Preventing nude image sharing at the device level requires either client-side scanning of all communications or breaking end-to-end encryption entirely. That’s mass surveillance infrastructure installed on every phone, affecting every adult, every journalist, every abuse survivor using encrypted messaging, every person who has ever sent a legal private image to another consenting adult. And unlike our lunch analogy, a family or student, nor an unaffiliated person altogether, has little to no option to opt out should they use one of these major platforms/devices. The harm of the intervention is categorically larger than the harm it addresses.

        A better analogy: should a parent leave alcohol or an unsecured firearm accessible to a child? No, and we hold parents accountable for that. We don’t require routine home inspections of every household to verify compliance. The accountability lands on the person who chose to bring the dangerous item into proximity with the child and who controls access to it. The parent pays for the phone. The parent pays for the data plan. The parent hands the child the device. The tools to monitor and restrict that device already exist, provided by the large platforms, on routers, etc, and are largely unused.

        The problem is real. The solution being proposed requires dismantling privacy for everyone to address the failures of some. There are targeted interventions that haven’t been exhausted. Those who stand to benefit are not the children, but the companies able to profit off the data collected and the governments able to invade privacy where there wasn’t said existing infrastructure to do so.

        This is a controlling party (government/private companies) abusing a moral panic which has been common throughout history. Just look at the Patriot Act.

        • dogdeanafternoon@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          5 months ago

          I mostly agree with everything you say, except for one thing.

          I’m pretty sure it’s technically possible to detect nude images, on device, 100% securely, without anyone ever knowing it was detected. This probably isn’t the approach that some corporations will take, but as far as I am aware, this is how the current nude detection on iPhone works. It’s all on device, and just blurs it so the user has to accept a warning before seeing the content. If you control your phone, you can disable it. If it’s a phone setup for a child, the child cannot disable it. It’s up to the parent to specify what the child is allowed to do.

          • godsammitdam@lemmy.zip
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            5 months ago

            Fair point, and I’ll concede, but only partially, as it is nit what is being discussed here. Starmer’s proposal isn’t asking for Apple to expand their system, it’s mandating platforms to comply and make it impossible, and the platforms can choose how to do so. On-device detection that never leaves the device is a meaningfully different privacy profile than server-side scanning or breaking E2E encryption. Apple’s Communication Safety feature works roughly as you described and that architecture is less invasive than the worst case scenario. If every implementation were genuinely on-device, opt-in, parent-controlled, and open source verifiable, it would be a different conversation.

            But that’s where my concession stops.

            We can only take a corporation’s word that it’s truly on-device and nothing is retained. The history of that promise is not encouraging. There have been multiple instances across the industry of companies guaranteeing on-device processing only for that data to appear in breach disclosures afterward. Closed, proprietary systems cannot be independently verified. We’re being asked to trust the architecture of companies whose entire business model is built on data extraction.

            There’s also a false positive problem. Google has already implemented similar detection and there are confirmed cases of users having their entire Google accounts permanently locked after photographing their own child in the bath. Emails, photos, Drive, business files, income streams, all gone, with no meaningful appeals process. The harm from a false positive in a system like this isn’t a minor inconvenience, it’s potentially catastrophic and irreversible.

            And then there’s the infrastructure problem. The Patriot Act is, once again, the prime example. You build the architecture for one stated purpose and then it gets legislated into something broader. Age verification is the live example happening right now. It started as self-attestation. That wasn’t sufficient so it became on-device ID verification. That wasn’t sufficient so it became third party trusted providers. Private vendors like Persona and kID. Both of which have had documented breaches after promising on-device verification themselves. This is literally the documented trajectory of every surveillance infrastructure built in the name of protection.

            It’s never a matter of if they legislate it further. It’s when. And who profits from the expanded version.

  • cheers_queers@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    wouldnt it be so funny if polaroid cameras made a huge comeback? i already fight the urge to buy one when i see shit like this

  • foxfell@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    How much he gives to his own citizens human trafficking kids from albania?

  • WorldsDumbestMan@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    Sure, give them 3 months to finish posting child diddy images, instead of idk, NOW. A week or two max, followed by forced liquidation.

      • WorldsDumbestMan@lemmy.today
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        5 months ago

        Heck they need 3 months to stop committing crimes? If I went murdering people, they would not give me 3 months to stop, they would hunt me down like a dog.

        • ArcaneSlime@lemmy.dbzer0.com
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          5 months ago

          Though tbf “underage people sharing nudes with each other on snapchat and looking at porn” doesn’t necessarily mean you have to kill the children immediately, you can give them some time.

          Besides, it’s “you have three months to create and implement code that tracks the ages of all your users and all activity across all apps for the ones under 18, and then use that to stop their cameras from working when nudity detected, and stop their messaging services when nudity detected, and stop their internet when pornography detected.” I don’t think we need the follow up “lethal force engaged” just yet, but you never know they may start blowing up computers like Mossad’s pagers when a kid googles “boobies” soon enough.

          • WorldsDumbestMan@lemmy.today
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            5 months ago

            I mean, I said Liquidate the company. What can you do, teens can be teens, it’s kind of like animals breeding. You are not supposed to breed the animals yourself. Also, they might hurt each other, so you should at least try to avoid situations where they will, or get them protection (so sex ed is a thing for that reason).

            But I have a hard time believing companies about anything, and I give them little benefit of doubt.

            When you put it like that: Age verification, checking the nudes of minors using code gained from Arceus knows what, it does sound a bit…unreasonable.

  • CommanderCloon@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    It would be so fun if Apple and Google decided they’d rather not have business in England anymore

    • Echo Dot@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      5 months ago

      It actually shows that the government have no understanding of the technology or the culture because no one’s communicating with potential paedophiles via iMessage does Google even have a messaging app anymore?

      • qarbone@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        5 months ago

        Google does have a text message app. I use it because the native Samsung one looked ass

        • kalpol@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          5 months ago

          Textra is a good SMS app. I haven’t looked st their privacy practices, but SMS in general is not private

  • themurphy@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    Fucking hell, can we get an age and qualification limit on politicians already?

  • Mearcfara@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    Yeah bro we’re totally just scanning everything you send just on the off chance that a child (even though you have none and don’t know any) are takes your phone and uses it to send a dick pic haha no bro don’t worry it’s for their safety haha

    • pinball_wizard@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      5 months ago

      And, because Apple cares about us, they can create the Personal Pictures Privacy Pro subscription. A plan where any compromising images are kept out of public dark web Facebook groups, for the low price of $29.95 per month.

      Disclaimer: Privacy and security applied by your Personal Pictures Privacy Pro plan will be generated by mid-tier cost effective AI, which itself was trained on the work of the most affordable people who told us they were privacy and security experts.

    • Echo Dot@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      5 months ago

      I estimate about 3 months until an inevitable data breach where it turns out they actually keep copies of all of the images because of course they will.

  • deliriousdreams@fedia.io
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    Make it illegal for their parents to give them phones and computing devices that can send and receive pictures. Problem solves.

    No but seriously education for both parents and children. Because while I do believe these companies play their role in how children interact online and what they interact with, I don’t believe they’re going to be able to stop anyone from sending something or receiving something they want to send without invasive and possibly traumatic tactics that will effect people regardless of age group.

  • mlg@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    Not that it’s a good thing but don’t either of these companies have enough leverage to refuse with practically zero consequences?

    4chan didn’t care because of the absurd logic and they still haven’t been blocked because they know it would be stupid to do so.

    • deliriousdreams@fedia.io
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      5 months ago

      Nah. They haven’t been blocked because the entire site is based on anonymity and the whole of their business operations don’t involve the country in question.

      How do you moderate a site when most of the user base are anonymous and don’t sign up for accounts? There’s nothing to link them back to. How do you prove a child sent anything or received anything with no account? How do you build a paper trail that would support the case against 4chan?

      • bingusBongus@mas.to
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        5 months ago

        @deliriousdreams
        moderate them by banning IPs, banning posts with VPNs, Tor and residential proxies from posting.
        I guess you cant prove a child sent anything if they never imply their age in any post, they just have to never slip up.
        I dont know if you need a paper trail against a website that just refuses to comply with laws. i dont know how UK laws work though. it is suprising 4chan isnt banned yet
        @themachinestops @mlg

    • Johnmannesca@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      5 months ago

      If one party decides to make the country an open air prison, all it does is secure political victory towards their opposition party that intend to reverse those changes. The flag might change, but the methods stay the same.

  • rob200@retrofed.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 months ago

    The idea is good but even with ai measures minors can easily fake an ai face id verification. I don’t think it’s possible to prevent 100% of cases.

    But hopefully if this actual results in the ai tech improving at preventing a over whelming majority of kids faking their ages it would be extremely rare. If not… the amount of fines tech companies might risk facing could potentially bankrupt them if too many kept sneeking past the ai and the gov acted against Google for that. the fines for that type of content isn’t usually a small matter.