The Dark Tower series by Stephen King. The ending is just chefs kiss and made me think about my Dark Tower
Stormlight Archive/Oathbringer.
Journey Before Destination.
Huge Spoiler for Book 3
The most important words a man can say are, “I will do better.” These are not the most important words any man can say. I am a man, and they are what I needed to say.
The ancient code of the Knights Radiant says “journey before destination.” Some may call it a simple platitude, but it is far more. A journey will have pain and failure. It is not only the steps forward that we must accept. It is the stumbles. the trials. The knowledge that we will fail. That we hurt those around us.
But if we stop, if we accept the person we are when we fall, the journey ends.
That failure becomes our destination.
To love the journey is to accept no such end. I have found, through painful experience, that the most important step a person can take is always the next one.
I’ve had more than too many life threatening events. Along with family, therapy, proactive steps to improve my life, I took to heart “life before death”. When I would be in a bad mental/emotional place, that was a strong mantra to help me get back on track. Thank you, Brandon Sanderson.
Stranger in A Strange Land was called “the hippy bible” for a reason…
It was written in the 1960s tho, so even the “woke” parts can be pretty problematic. That just means society progresses tho. If 60 year old media doesn’t have anything problematic in it, it means society has stalled instead of peogressed
Thou are God.
The problems with this book are not just “a product of it’s time”. There were authors at the time who could write women characters, Heinlen just wasn’t one of them.
This was my favorite book when I was in my mid 20s. I tried to read it a couple of years ago and just couldn’t.
I’ve always had problems with Heinlein. Early on, my problems were more that his dialogue just seemed… too pat. He couldn’t separate his characters in his mind, so they always had the perfect comebacks to what each other were saying.
And as I got older, I have more and more problem with his women. But then again, I adore Isaac Asimov, and he can’t write women well, either. But better than Heinlein.
I would say that Asimov cannot write human characters. All his characters are almost robotic. I still love his writing, and he plays with logical reasoning extremely well, but I wouldn’t go to him for well-rounded characters
I liked the engineer types in I, Robot. I thought they were dated (as they were dated when I read them in the 80s and 90s), but decently reasonable. heh.
But honestly, I have a hard time arguing too stringently against your asssertion. lol. Especially women, but yes, he was more comfortable with science than people.
Then again, the times I’ve tried writing… I’m not good at writing people and I figured that out. But for me, I think it’s the ADHD. I don’t know what the hell normal people do. lol
I honestly believe Asimov was far in the autism spectrum because of how he describes people as purely rational beings.
Talking about I, Robot and talking as a woman in STEM, he actually was quite good in noticing how the environment was not woman-friendly and deduce from there. The main woman in the story is a very recognizable character. (I forgot her name, she is stern and strict, good at her job but has no personal life outside of it. You feel she has too battle against the environment at every turn, and even while being really good at her job her department is a one-person group)
You know, over the past day or so in this topic… I’m starting to wonder and/or maybe realize that’s probably a thing. I have severe ADHD, and when I’ve self-evaluated for autism, score incredibly high on the social side (not so much on the texture/hobby sides). I’ve always had some troubles with understanding some of my fellow humans (while at other times feeling like I had special insights in some situations)… maybe that’s one reason I liked Asimov more than some. lol
Also: Susan Calvin, one of my favorite characters. :)
I’ve recently come to terms with the fact that I am somewhat on the spectrum as well, and suddenly quite some things make sense. In particular the type of writing that I like and how I express myself… I mean, I started reading again in my late teens to figure out how people tick, so, yeah
The Left Hand of Darkness and other Le Guin stories. Good timing on when I started expending my scifi reading in her direction; I was in high school, meeting more people outside my little conservative family and church bubble, trying to form new conceptual models for the much bigger world that I was previously insulated from.
I have to drop “The Dispossessed” here.
The Left Hand of the Darkness was one of the few times I saw my partner cry for a book.
I recently read The Word for World is Forest, and while a smaller story it’s still really good. While The Ones that walk away from Omelas is extremely impactful.
Of her I often say: even her shits were pure gold.
Anything by Le Guin. She’s a revolutionary and visionary. Imo greatest sci-fi author ever.
Le Guin is phenomenal. Her acceptance speech at the 65th National Book Awards makes me tear up to this day.
“Hard times are coming, when we’ll be wanting the voices of writers who can see alternatives to how we live now, can see through our fear-stricken society and its obsessive technologies to other ways of being, and even imagine real grounds for hope. We’ll need writers who can remember freedom — poets, visionaries — realists of a larger reality.”
Edit: Here’s the full speech if anyone is interested in listening to it. It’s only six minutes and well-worth it.
D-D-D-Dark Souls 3. A great resource for the depressed.
You wanna know more? Go play the game. It’s very good. :3
Pff. You can’t just imply that anyone will understand a story by playing a fromsoft game.
Oh no! I did not mean to imply that. Let me try again:
“Dark Souls 3 is a great resource for people with depressio due to it’s core game play loop. Wanna find out why exactly? Go and play it >:)”
Phew. That could have been catastrophic. Thanks for pointing that out.
Whew!
Redwall - I didn’t realize when I was reading the series but looking back now they absolutely instilled in me the knowledge that I could stand up to those in power despite being weaker or smaller. Those books lead to me rebelling against my abusive parents and striking out on my own. I shed their conservative views and hatred. All because a mouse and his friends stood up to a rat.
I’ve got more but this one probably had the largest impact on how I think overall in the long term.
The Watchmen
when I say 1984 it is going to be very cleche but hear me out
so I grow up in China and only moves out around 12 when I was 10 they suddenly banned a book that the name is just a year I get super confused and pleed the local Liberian to read it before they destory it. holy shit that is some messed up shit for my age at the time, but it made be see the environment around me a lot more clearlyHow ironic to ban 1984 lol
There’s plenty I could list, but when it comes to seeing the world through a new lens it’s all about Discworld. Just keep reading and it’ll change you. Sir Pratchett’s understanding of people, society, and philosophy is phenomenal.
Small Gods is probably one of the greatest books I’ve ever read. I fucking love it so much.
I’ve wanted to read the series for a while, but getting into it seems so intimidating because of just how much Sir Terry wrote. Do you have a good starting recommendation?
While there are recurring characters, locations, themes and ideas, each book is an independent, self contained story. As the other commenter mentioned, it doesn’t really matter where you start.
Also, there may be a large number of books, but they are all really short and easy/quick to read. I went from being intimidated by the number of books in the series when I picked up The Colour of Magic to crying during the epilogue in The Sheppard’s Crown in an eye blink.
Obligatory, here’s what I got post lol
Wyrd sisters…was not expecting the quiz to so heavily focus me on witches…not sure if thats a feature or a bug of my interpreting, idk much about discworld but maybe there’s only like 5 starter books and that’s why it focused me on witches so much.
Not that I’m an expert, but I did create /r/Discworld, so I got to see a lot of opinions.
There’s a couple of main philosophies. The one I agree with less is reading “subseries”. First of all, many books really imho cross thos lines anyway, so you’re going to miss stuff… but… that’s one option.
The thing is, Sir Pratchett himself wasn’t so happy with his first coupld of books. The Colour of Magic is a bit different - he was writing as a parody of fantasy. But as he went along, things kinda took off and it became a thing.
Frankly, my advice: Just suck it up. Colour of Magic isn’t bad. Commit to at least reading through Mort, which is IIRC the 4th novel.
If that makes you nervous, then choose one or more of the traditional starting ones: Mort, Small Gods, Guards! Guards!. If you read all three of those and like it, just go back to Colour of Magic and read in publication order. The world evolves as he writes and it’s a better experience.
But if you get enthralled with the night watch over the witches or whatever, the google “Discworld reading guide” and you’ll find it and can see the “subseries” and do as you please.
If you’re anything like me, though, starting at around Mort and from then on… I always read a novel when it came out and it was pretty good, but when I re-read it almost immediately, I noticed so many more things. That’s how I fell in love with the books. They are not one-time reads.
I’m on around my eighth or so full readthrough of the entire series - on Making Money right now. I don’t think everyone will do that many, but for me, almost all the books are old friends, and I still notice new little details.
His writing is so… compact. So many scenes with more than one subtext going on. He often writes scenes with dialogue happening that’s critical to the story, but something in the background that just adds to the world might be happening at the same time.
I think specifically where a couple of bumbling night watch are talking about something, but as they’re sitting there, they’re watching a man slowly paint the name of his boat on his boat, but instead of painting “PRIDE OF ANKH-MORPORK” he’s painted “PRID”, so they’re talking back and forth, anticipating the painter noticing… and at the end of the scene, he does. And it’s just so… so human, so delightful. The novels truly taught me the beauty of humanity.
There is, however, probably no real wrong way to read them. Someone on r/discworld claimed to be reading them in literally reverse publication order and enjoying them. So that’s probably valid. But I would say: publication order hands down. Or whatever way you’ll actually go out and get started. :)
choose one or more of the traditional starting ones: Mort, Small Gods, Guards! Guards!. If you read all three of those and like it, just go back to Colour of Magic and read in publication order. The world evolves as he writes and it’s a better experience.
This here. This is what I recommend to everyone I introduce to Discworld.
I haven’t kept count of how many readthroughs I’ve done, but every few years I do one too. I had my copy of Guards Guards rebound recently because it was literally falling to pieces.
We lost all our books to Hurricane Michael, but for me, this is not so much a problem as I struggle with books these days, but my phone works fine as a reader, so I have them all electronically. :)
Discworld as a collection is intimidating. The real secret is that it’s not a series, but a kind of pile. You can really start almost anywhere and read whatever.
That said, there’s kind of short sets with the same characters in groups throughout the books. I’d point people to these ones as reasonable starting points:
- Equal Rites
- Guards! Guards!
- Mort
I’m sure other people will have various other suggestions or opinions and we’re all likely correct for our own reasons. There’s very little in Discord that isn’t top tier writing.
When in doubt, start with the Watch: Guards! Guards!. Can’t go wrong.
Those are the first 3 I read (first was GG, second Mort, third ER) because they all seemed recommended starting places. They are all origins of different sets of characters, so there isn’t much back lore for any of those 3, so it gives you a very broad look at life on the Disc.
After finishing those, I knew I’d want to read them all, so then I went and started from the beginning and the rest of the books made much more sense than I think they would skipping about and you’d get light spoilers, seeing maybe some characters being good guys when they weren’t in earlier stories or different groups gaining acceptance due to conflicts being resolved (or not).
It’s doesn’t really matter where you start but realize that it’s a bunch of stories that are told of the same place. So there’s stories about set characters and some of just one story of the characters. The wizards are something that runs through all the stories so it really does make sense to start with The Color of Magic. It will introduce you to the style of story that will fill out the whole thing.
There’s the witches, the wizards, Death, the watch, and books about the other guild’s. The witches are a lot of fun. If you don’t really care for the specific group, you you can jump around in order. Mostly once you understand the groups, you can read anything in whatever order
There’s no bad onramp to that world. Very few of the books require you to have read the others, and there isn’t much of a strict chronology. Apparently Pratchett recommended that people start with Sourcery, but that’s not set in stone.
On r/discworld, Mort, Guards! Guards!, and Small Gods were the three most recommended ones to start, besides those like me who argue for publication order (with the disclaimer about the first 2-3 or so)
Near the end of my first read through, and it’s been hard for me to believe one guy wrote so many different points of view so well. I’ve been given both a lot of new perspectives to consider, and I’ve gotten good reminders of things that I already believed, but had gotten a little bit forgotten as things happen and I’ve become a little jaded toward some things.
Lately, having just finished Making Money, I’ve been thinking again about what type of ruler Lord Vetinari is. He’s got a lot of aspects that I feel I wouldn’t like to him and his leadership style, but I also feel no one comes close to being a better choice for Ankh-Morepork. Plot armor certainly helps, but whenever he puts plots in motion, it’s hard to argue with results,
I also like how the Nights Watch doesn’t get rid of its derelicts, it finds ways for them to be successful. I have been around some very difficult people, but very few that are totally useless, and once you can narrow down what their strengths are, you can find a lot of value and often a decent person in most everyone.
Also a big fan of Death! Some of the best moments of justice and sweetest of rewards have come from him.
I’ve been thinking again about what type of ruler Lord Vetinari is.
He’s basically a benevolent dictator. He adopts the role of a tyrant for pragmatic reasons, but he seems to sincerely care about the well-being of Ankh-Morporkians.
It makes me wonder if that’s ever truly possible. And I’m not as sure it’s the citizens he protects so much as the city itself. He’s either at least been partially responsible for some killings and will let people die when it benefits not so much himself, but the proper functioning of the city.
Someone like him seems crucial to ensuring a great society, but how do you find someone like that, what would keep them from crossing the line into a less altruistic authority, and what does that society do when that person is inevitably gone?
Him and House from Fallout have been two people I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about. Both are capable of bringing order out of chaos, but it’s a very fine line they seem to walk.
I like Vetinari in fiction, but I’m unsure how I’d feel in real life. To most people he is still scary and seemingly a threat. Only a select few know most of it is just reputation and show.
And I’m not as sure it’s the citizens he protects so much as the city itself
I think he’d consider that a distinction without difference. The city is the citizens.
He’s either at least been partially responsible for some killings and will let people die when it benefits not so much himself, but the proper functioning of the city.
The “proper functioning of the city” is a state of relative harmony and peace between the citizens. Most of those that found their end at his direction were rather opposed to the “proper functioning of the city”.
what does that society do when that person is inevitably gone?
I surmise that much of his efforts in building the integrity of the city, and its institutions, might be said to constitute an inoculation of sorts against any “greedy and clumsy” successors.
I do like book Vetinari, purely because we do have those insights to his thought process and that as he’s a fictional character, his methods will work as intended.
As I’ve watched the representative democracy in the US make its faults very obvious, it’s got me questioning other types of leadership. Distributed power like communism or anarchism have some appealing features, but radically changing any government seems to require some form of authoritarianism to see the change through and to maintain it. That seems a lot like what Vetinari did to stabilize the city. He’s great as a fictional leader, and I think his grey areas highlight some important differences between him, and let’s say, Carrot.
Thinking we could find a real life Vetinari is what still concerns me about a political revolution, as so many real people will promise what he brought to a place like Ankh, but then instead prioritize themselves. He makes me both believe a little more that we could have a successful change in governance, but then everything in the real world reminds me it is fiction. Not impossible, but not likely as real humans are so fallible.
Discworld books feel the opposite of real life in that way. In the books, we know more of Vetinari than we do of the life of most peasants, and what we do know of those peasants, we know they fear Vetinari and think he’s kinda evil, while we the readers know he’s not. In real life, we see leaders try and present the good side, usually to con us, and be evil behind the scenes. If we saw someone acting like Vetinari, most of us would probably not support him, although Trumpism shows that to maybe not be so reliable, but I’m not sold on him really being altruistic behind the scenes for many, many reasons.
So while I support Vetinari in the books, it just feel paradoxical how we could ever get such a leader for real.
Yes the benevolent dictator archetype only really works in fiction. Philosopher kings have been suggested as the most efficient form of government for thousands of years, but the difficulty is in finding them in the real world. We could never fully trust any would-be tyrant.
I’d say benevolent dictators are absolutely possible, but they are impossible to plan for. If there is room for any dictator, there is no good way to filter that to only benevolent ones. I think the best practical political systems tend to assume people will not be benevolent, so try and set things up so that people are incentivized to act benevolently as much as possible.
Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy
What did I take from it? I personally took the point to be “world’s fucked, people are fucked, but who cares? Goof off more!”
Whatever the biggest take away is, depends on context…
The second biggest take away tho, is always: Don’t Panic
The lock screen on my phone says in big friendly letters “Don’t Panic”
Same. If I am ever going to get a tattoo, it will day “Don’t panic” in big friendly letters as well. It’s… fitting nowadays.
And don’t forget your towel!
Ishmael by Daniel Quinn.
It’s not so much the critique of anthropocentrism or infinite growth that changed my thinking; I was already on board with those. It was the idea that we behave like this because of the myth, the story we believe about ourselves, rather than some inherent quality.
Still not sure if I believe it fully, but it’s a thinker.
Late reply here, but thanks for the recommendation, I checked it out from the library and really enjoyed it. It could have been written a year or two ago rather than in 1992.
Awesome, glad you enjoyed it. I’m a big fan of how the story is delivered. Socratic dialogue with a telepathic ape makes it hit different
Cloud Atlas (I feel like every book post I make is about Cloud Atlas) It taught me two important lessons.
- We’re not kind enough to each other and
- Even if a goal seems hopeless it’s worth making the attempt if you see something wrong in the world.
All quiet on the western front. It’s short. It’s good. The OG Nazis hated it. Read it.
(The title alone is „Baby-shoes-never-worn“ level of sad)
The movie is a masterpiece
The original movie maybe, but the most recent netflix one felt like it cut out every scene from the book that made you actually feel for the main character. By the end of the book you understand on an empathetic level that Paul’s choice in the last scene of the book is a mercy to himself. The author deeply explores so much more then the horrors of war itself, brothership, the rich/powerful treating humans like game pieces, the effects of propaganda on those who are living the opposite reality, how the ones away from the front turn their backs on helping the troops despite being the loudest voice for pushing the war further. There is so much more to the book and its sad that such an viciously real story is dumbed down to “war bad and scary”
I didn’t know about any remakes, the original movie is what I was referring to. I have never read the book but I did study the film and it is a special thing. Especially in regards to humanizing the enemy and realizations about propaganda and the pain of understanding
Ah I fully take back my comment then. Ironically ive read the book but haven’t gotten around to watching the first movie
When people talk about the All Quiet on the Western Front movie their usually referring to the 2022 Netflix adaptation since the last adaptation was in 1979, and before that 1930. I’ve heard great things about the 1930 adaptation but have no clue which your talking about :0
I didn’t even know that there was a 1979 version lol
The only way to watch it is the 1930s version. It’s very iconic and the cinematography is a masterpiece
Asimov’s Foundation Trilogy instilled in me a deep faith in science above all else. And a lot of hope that, even if times can suck, overall we have been developing and live has been getting better and better. I am way more cynical now, but I still hold on the hope that eventually everything will be fine.
There’s definitely a lot in Foundation to aspire to. And Asimov’s writing in general - the zeroth law, for example. It’d be nice to have his robots with the three (yea four) laws, for sure.
Fahrenheit 451. I started noticing increasing censorship and the growing intentional denial of knowledge and learning more and more. It’s terrifying.













