- cross-posted to:
- politicalmemes@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- politicalmemes@lemmy.world
When did politics make it better for the poor? We still seem to have alot of poor people.
If the solution was politics, wouldn’t the problem be solved?
I mean, the definition of “poor people” has shifted somewhat over time. I don’t think there will ever not be poor people, but is nice that poor people often have access to healthcare etc these days… at least in any country that has sane politics
Here where we don’t have sane politics, it’s not the availability of medical care that is the problem, it is the cost.
Also most practitioners do not want to deal with anything that is out of the ordinary.
Social struggle is political struggle. The civil rights movement was a political struggle. Socialist revolutions were political struggles. When people say politics matters, we aren’t saying that the capitalist state can be bent to help working people. We are stating that it is through social engagement that real victories are won.
I agree with that, and we see that in history very clearly too.
“Do politics” in this case refers to talking about anything that can be perceived as political.
Obviously people need to be willing to talk about issues before we can fix them, instead of everyone with privilege choosing to ignore it until they personally are affected.
I think we live in a world where money decides everything, and it’s very rare that we don’t have solutions to our problems.
Its just not profitable.
We don’t have a system that optimizes for quality of life or satisfaction for the many.
Money “solves” things in favor of money, not in favor of people, which is why houses are so fucking expensive right now - young adults see most of their income taken away to pay for housing so they even have fewer children, whilst those who already have the most money make even more money with their realestate investments.
It’s also the reason for enshittification - the competition of free market capitalism definitelly optimizes the system … for making more money for those who own the companies and investments, not for higher quality or cheaper products: if a market is bound by high barriers to entry (say, memory or water supply), you get cartels and even monopolies and those won’t don’t need to make better products at a cheaper price to compete, so instead they try and extract as much money from costumers as possible with the cheapest possible production costs.
Capitalism only ever improves things for anything else than capital as a side effect of improvings things for capital: companies pay betters salaries only ever when otherwise they would not have the workers that create the wealth that investors capture, they make better and cheaper products only ever when otherwise they would be making less money by selling inferior and more expensive products and services. Unsurprisingly, were a market’s structure herds customers and/or keeps away competition - marketing shapes consumer choices much more than quality or price, networking effects pull people to a handful of providers, physical constrainst make it harder or even impossible for competition to enter the market - it invariably ends up expensive and enshittified.
I asked chat gpt what system it think would produce a system where most people are happy and it suggested the same system as in nordic countries:
If the objective is high average living standards while keeping poverty, insecurity and extreme concentrations of power relatively low, one model worth looking at closely is the social-democratic mixed economy used, in different forms, in the Nordic countries.
It is still a market economy: people can own companies, become wealthy, invest, compete and make profits. But the market is constrained by institutions designed to spread the gains more broadly:
-
private enterprise and competitive markets for most goods and services
-
strong unions and collective bargaining, so workers have negotiating power rather than relying entirely on employers
-
universal healthcare, education, pensions and social insurance
-
relatively progressive taxation and substantial redistribution
-
unemployment protection and retraining, so losing a job is less catastrophic
-
regulation of monopolies, workplace conditions and environmental damage
-
publicly provided infrastructure and services
-
usually some combination of public, cooperative and private ownership rather than insisting everything must be privately owned
There is empirical support for several of those mechanisms. OECD research finds that taxes and transfers substantially reduce market-income inequality, although the effect differs considerably between countries.
research finds that greater collective-bargaining coverage is associated with smaller wage disparities, and that labour-market institutions can counteract some of the inequality created by concentrated employer power.
Nordic tax-and-benefit systems have historically produced comparatively low poverty and inequality after taxes and transfers, together with high employment.
Its so nice when people label their comment as AI in the first sentence. I appreciate you saving me the time it takes to read it.
Thank you. Sincerely, no sarcasm.
The Nordic countries are declining like the rest of the capitalist world, and like other western countries rely on imperialism to begin with.
If I wanted word salad from a statistical parrot I would ask for it myself.
Thanks for actually proving the lack of intellect I suspected from your previous post having such a simpleton take on Economics.
Ok :)
-
A lot of progress has been made, e.g. the abolishing of child labor. There’s this weird thing of taking whatever we have now as a baseline, thus ignoring all historical achievements.
Comparing our information age society to feudalism is not the win you expected.
When did politics make it better for the poor?
Is this a serious question? Because there’s a shit ton of examples.
You don’t have to be a fan of China to acknowledge that their government lifted hundreds of millions (nearly 1 billion by some reports) of people out of extreme poverty in the last 40 or so years.
That’s true. China is impressive!
I’m a white male with depression and a long standing medical issue that has consumed my life (Water on the brain… I have had so many surgeries and stays in hospital)
I still say fuck Israel, Fuck everyone that loves Israel!
The top orangutan has been accused of murdering babies and pregnant teens that he raped. So I would assume most of us Americans are unaffected since nobody is even investigating anything like that. Oh they investigated Cesar Chavez and there was much reason to do so and the biggest accuser was also part of the movement. But not the uber-rich. No siry Bob.
“i dont do politcs” people when politics do them:

Right wing chuds, when the “ban pornography to protect the children” act bans their hentai, and not just trans people from public life (trans people are bad, because they got tricked by them (read: got “gay bamboozled” on 4chan with femboy hentai)):
You don’t do politics either. You just roleplay like your opinion has any impact and in reality you’re just annoying.
I’d just say politics is a good hobby
I’m starting to understand “I don’t do politics.” to often mean “I don’t have the mental aptitude for political discourse and have spent a significant amount of my life becoming educated on other subjects or otherwise being unintellectual about most subjects.” I feel it’s a little more acceptable that way. Some people are just not that smart or have not invested much time in politics or current world affairs. It usually means, they feel inadequate discussing the subject with you.
Teeny weenie bit hyperbolic, dont you think? By that logic, politicians are the greatest geniuses that ever walked the earth. People don’t bother with politics to avoid assholes that can’t shut up about it.
I never said that at all… I said literally nothing about politicians and I said nothing to suggest it’s the most intelligent subject. You made that context up all on your own. I said that many people who don’t talk politics don’t for the exact same reason you might not talk about computers with someone who knows a lot about computers. You might also avoid conversation about gardening with someone who has kept gardens for years. It’s not necessarily because of a lack of intelligence (though in some cases it is) but most likely just not the subject matter they have the most knowledge of. Not everyone can spend the time immersing themselves in all the subject matter you have and politics is just another subject.
To be fair it reads like you heavily correlate being political, to intellectual.
By that logic more political = more intelligent.
I understand you didn’t mean it that way, but it’s not hard to see why someone would assume that.
I feel like that’s a flawed understanding of what intelligence is. You can be smart regarding some things and braindead with others. Intelligence is not linear where all particular subject matter just comes with having high intellect.
I completely agree.
That’s why I disagree with your initial suggestion that someone who “doesn’t do politics” probably “doesn’t have the mental aptitude for it”.
Part of politics are like this. Like when you hear about people in white house doing terrible things. And you’re like who is this guy? “Oh he’s the secretary of defense.” What’s that mean? And soon it feels like if someone was trying to teach me about the people in Keeping up with the Kardashians. Or some other reality show.
But then other ones are like…We are cutting funding for poor people and welfare. And that should be cut and dry.
They’re terrified that if they think about it too much or learn too much about it that they will have their mind changed and be alienated by their family/friends/communities.
Some are just incredibly stupid, but I’d say most are just fucking cowards.
You’re seeing fear and cowardice where there is none. Nobody is “scared” of learning about politics.
To make such an assumption is… odd.
So, why are you so afraid?
So, why are you so afraid?
I’m not afraid to learn about politics and challenging the ideals of the people around me, which is more than I can say for the magats who live in fear of daddy not loving them anymore when they tell him Trump is a moron.
You don’t think these people are scared? I do. I think they’re terrified. I’m not so sure why you’re defending magats, though.
I don’t think those who “don’t do politics” are privileged. Many simply easily feel depressed hearing of bad news and literally tune out of the constant news cycle. But as others have pointed out, regardless of the reason for not doing politics, politics eventually do them. Plato once said that not being engaged in politics is letting inferiors rule over them. And oh boy, the world is experiencing first hand being ruled over by manbabies.
Edit: it was Plato not Socrates who made the statement
It is rooted in a form of privilege though to be able to just tune it out because it’s depressing
I didn’t do politics when I was a younger man. It wasn’t depressing or anything. It just didn’t exist in my world. I didn’t watch TV, listen to the radio. I did the things which I enjoyed and politics was a million miles from that. That did change within a few years though once I caught on.
And that is why I didn’t vote at the time. I didn’t feel “qualified” to vote because I had no idea about any of it. And that is what worries me the most in present time. People who vote without any idea what they’re voting for, or worse, people who are voting on a very narrow topic and nothing else. “Stop the boats” comes to mind.
bush era is many of still in k-12 became aware of politics, if bush hadnt gone to war all over, i think people would still be voting for the same milquetoast candidates without much outrage.
Some people also just get scared at arguing even if its friendly, because it reminds them of their parents and brings up trauma.

Either that or worked to the bone and left with no energy to organise.
Ironically, too much progressivism is accelerating the western world back to the dark ages fast.
Also, regarding the worst genocide since WWII: An estimated 70 to 85 million people died worldwide during World War II, while cumulative legal abortions in major Western countries (such as roughly 60–64 million in the U.S. since 1973 and over 10 million in the UK since 1967) total tens of millions, though a single comprehensive aggregate total for all of Western countries combined is not centrally tracked. Also more black people get aborted than anyone else.
Fuck Israel, Palestine & anyone else who kills innocents.
I’m not political btw. 🖕🏽
Ironically, too much progressivism is accelerating the western world back to the dark ages fast.
You are the domestic abuser yelling “look what you made me do” while throwing haymakers at a unconscious person.
Whoa how did you know?
You definitely are political
And stupid
Very stupid
Wow what a transphobe
How do you figure that, genius?
My IQ is 300 and my gigantic basketball sized brain knows all. Explaining to you would be like teaching one plus one to an ant. Impossible.
Uhhh…
…huh, nvm. Not worth my time
Fortunately my time is worthless. Got your back brother.
Thank you for your time
Sometimes; when you hear somebodies political take, you can instantly tell they fall in one of the two extremely simplistic, easily marketable positions. When this happens, the easiest thing to do is politely decline to discuss politics with them, because you know they lack the nesessary context to understand your well thought out, nuanced position.
If you never encounter this problem, I suspect you may be in one of these two camps, and would strongly encourage you to think about your politics in detail. Do you know why you believe what you do?
Ok, but in a practical scenario, elections are happening and we only got 2 candidates for the main role, each from one of those two extremely simplistic, easily marketable positions. What will you do?
Work at the state level to replace First-past-the-post voting with a voting system that let’s people transfer their vote if their first preference doesn’t win.
I’m assuming “I don’t do politics” in this scenario is abstaining from debate, not abstaining from voting at all. Of course you go with the side that aligns best with your beliefs.
My point is, if you’re talking to someone, and all they’re doing is waiting to see which shibboleths you spit out to decide if they hate you or love you, then you aren’t going to get any meaningful discussion out of them.
If I tell you “I don’t do politics” it means I don’t want to argue about this shit right now.
Man the same post on reddit is wild, people wanting to implement auto bans for people who are apolitical like somehow that will help.
Oh i don’t really do reddit
I’m privileged enough to use Lemmy so why should i care ?
Reddit is a perfect example of the results of heavy-handed, politically motivated moderation.
No matter what happens, they are always flabbergasted and oblivious, cursed to never comprehend the big bad world around them.
How many tens of thousands of people did they ban for daring to suspect a lab leak for COVID?
Meanwhile, it was a lab leak. Good job, morons.
Man it was really funny last US election cycle with every redditor declaring that Kamala Harris won the election only for the result to be the complete opposite.
Liberals have really been going full mask off the last ten years. I appreciate the honesty.












