Welcome again to everybody. Make yourselves at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread!
P.S. Update on those stability improvements/enhancements I mentioned in my previous weekly thread: they’re finished. The matrix server uptime is now better. Suspiciously better, some might say. Anyway, enjoy the reliability >:3
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Theory discussion group on /c/theory@lemmygrad.ml
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive
I wonder if English is gonna become something like Latin in the future.
Practically everything in computing is written in the English language.
I think it English as we speak it now will resemble Latin in the future in how Latin is used today but that it spawn its own set of offshoots as Latin did with Romance languages.
Inevitably the various regional Englishes will become their own languages. American English will be incomprehensible to Australian English speakers. The “English” part of the names will likely flat out be dropped.
I would hope in the future it is would be Chinese.
I am going to really struggle to learn chinese. Or will it be like firefly?
I have not seen Firefly, so I don’t know.
where you only curse in Chinese?
You are only allowed to curse in Chinese
I want to begin this comment by saying I am in no way perfect but holy shit the bar for dating men is low. Like, the stories I hear from women around me about people they meet either in rl or online are wild. It’s as if men are completely unable to function in a normal way.
Now I’m curious what you’re hearing in the specifics. Like bad hygiene? Strange views or attitudes? All of the above and more?
Always just attitude. If it isn’t manosphere bs it is just general antisocial behavior. Just not being able to have a conversation without hinting at sex within half an hour. Having no interest at all in the women they match. Wanting to meet at their place for the first date. I could go on and on really.
Like, I have autism and you’d expect me to struggle socially to some degree but the NT’s out there seem to be far worse for some reason.
Yikes, yeah, that sounds bad. Basically sounds like people who are interested in hookups and nothing more, but also aren’t being upfront about that in a mature, humanizing way if they’re going to go that route. I wonder how much of it is fueled by PUA (pickup artist) material out there; from what I understand, a lot of that stuff is very sexist at its core and frames women like they’re a game console with a Konami Code you need to put in to get sex (not that they are using that analogy specifically, but that it’s very objectifying).
the latest call of duty might be the worst piece of war propaganda i’ve ever seen, even worse than the previous games.
If they let you play as the DPRK though I might just have to pirate it 👀
Maybe I will too, so I can play the local player and be a North Korean shooting down American solider NPCs.
Was reading blackshirts and reds and remembered a certain subreddit (tankiejerk) when reading this passage:
Orwell (with Orwellian doublethink) characterized the condemnation of communism as a lonely courageous act of defiance. Today, his ideological progeny are still at it, offering themselves as intrepid left critics of the Left, waging a valiant struggle against imaginary Marxist-Leninist-Stalinist hordes.
Is deepseek less censored when answering in Chinese? I asked a question about Li Jishen and Li Zongren seperately and it initially bugged and gave answers in Chinese, but when I asked for it in English it gave me “that’s beyond my scope.” Idk I just found it odd
I think it’s just different censor training/algorithms. I have had it answer something in Chinese, then when I asked it to translate the answer to English it gave me a censor block. Mind you, I’ve not actually gotten a censorship message when it is generating chinese responses… But I have to assume they exist (not providing instructions for violence, self harm, etc ).
I don’t remember exactly what it got stuck on, but I think it had something to do Xi Jinping or some basics of Marxism, but I was pretty sure it was a fairly mundane question. I pasted the chinese answer into Google translate, looking at the translating, and I remember thinking “that’s very normal, why did this get sensored in English”
Crazy week this week.
To make the context as short as possible, I was unable to continue my Master in AI/data. I never really liked it anyway so it’s not a big deal, except when it comes to money obviously.
After that I decided to do a different Master (cuz it’s practically mandatory to get a somewhat well paid job).On Monday I had no information on my application. Then on Tuesday afternoon I was told I was good to go but since school started Monday I had to be there Wednesday morning.
Now I’m in a weird limbo state where for some services I am a proper student but others haven’t catch up yet. For example I have to prove that I went to school this afternoon but the application for that doesn’t recognize me yet.Tomorrow it’s my first proper day of school this year and because I missed the first two it’s gonna be artistic.
I don’t know if I’m making any sense, English is still not my main language, the French school/grade system doesn’t neatly match any other and I’m also pretty sleepy.
But hey, I wanted to talk about it somewhere.Glad to be back here, i think i was gone for a month
Given the fact that AI decompilation has become so widespread today, I can confidently say we are in a new age of piracy.
so good luck on finding the One Piece, comrades.
The first world war took place from 1756 to 1763. Change my mind.
Would that make Napoleonic Wars (1803–1815), WW2?
I guess so.
Marx’s mathematical manuscripts are very underrated. There’s this footnote which I think it’s pretty interesting despite being very vague:
Marx distinguishes in each equation two sides (where now we speak of two parts), the left hand and the right hand which do not always play symmetric roles. On the left-hand side of the equation he frequently places two different, equivalent expressions joined by the conjunction ‘or’. (source)
So, for Marx, x = y is not the same as y = x (even though they mean the same thing in modern math).
hi sorry i just realized the passage you attached here repeats itself! not bad or confusing i just got halfway through the repetition before thinking “wait a minute i’ve seen this before… like two seconds ago”
oh thanks, I didn’t notice
I am interested in doing math for fun ever since seeing an old Soviet mathematics textbook lol
You can tell Kamala is back in the running becaus the KHive just woke up after 2 years of silence. Marching orders have come down from Blue MAGA
Is this the most important election of your lives yet again?
Thoughts on this phrasing? “Capitalism is a system where society exists to serve commerce rather than commerce existing to serve society.”
As introductory rhetoric for criticizing capitalism in a somewhat less jargon heavy way, especially when talking to people who have pre-existing embedded anti-communism and so may be more reactive to obvious marxist critiques.
Then connecting it to examples: “In the capitalist US, society exists to serve commerce. In socialist China, commerce exists to serve society.”
Capitalism is a system where society exists to serve commerce rather than commerce existing to serve society.”
still feels jarogny. Maybe: Capitalism is a system in which society exists to further the growth of hoarded fortunes instead of fortunes being used to further the growth of society.
Fair. I probably underestimate the extent to which I’m using jargon sometimes…
I’ve made an effort to be more, idk, colloquial over the years in order to better communicate ML stuff. But I grew up around people who are (non-commie) nerdy and I pretty much embraced it. It doesn’t help that when I do read theory, some of it is academia language to the max and then it causes me to want to reuse that kind of language when talking about ML stuff.
I do think it is an important thing to improve on though. As Maeve pointed out:
I’ve been thinking about verbosity/garroulessness for several months, since I tend to swing from that to being terse to the point it seems rude. With declining literacy and reading comprehension rates in Western societies, it would behoove us to find a middle ground, since attention spans are also in serious decline, for many varied reasons, not the least of which is physical exhaustion and mental/emotional overwhelm.
Being able to meet people where they are at without also losing the core of something is a real pedagogical challenge. I appreciate your effort toward it. Makes me think of a dragon’s hoard.
Saying stuff in less technical terms while retaining the meaning is something LLMs are perfect for. Practicing on liberals on social media is a good way to hone your rhetoric.
Both good points!
This phrasing feels a bit cultural, I think? Like, couldn’t you also argue that Rome’s society existed mostly to generate slaves who worked to make products which were then sold on the market?
Fair. The phrase could probably be applied to exploitative systems predating capitalism and still make sense from a certain point of view. For that reason, it may be weaker as rhetoric than it could be.
Focusing on what makes capitalism unique may make it sharper, provided it doesn’t get lost in jargon. To that end, what does make capitalism unique even if in jargon form? On reflection, I’m not sure I could explain it simply, in a few words from recall. Something to do with private property and accumulation of capital, but that’s a bit vague. I think my internalized understanding of it is actually better than my verbalized one, if that makes sense; lived experience with it vs. theory language I guess.
Lenin defines Capitalism succinctly as
Capitalism is that stage in the development of commodity-production in which labour-power, too, becomes a commodity. (source)
The most important aspect of Capitalism is that the individual bourgeois exploits the entire proletariat class, rather than a group of people. This doesn’t happen in any other economic system.
Think of a slave-owner. They can exploit only the slaves they own. However, this means that they have the interest to take care of them since a loss of a slave means the loss of labor.
Meanwhile, a landlord doesn’t care who their tenants are or whether they have money for food after paying rent. There is always someone outside waiting for one apartment to get vacant.
The individual bourgeois has leverage over an entire class, so you have no leverage against them. The only leverage against the bourgeoisie is when the proletariat class gets organized. One individual is hopeless.
So, I think I would summarize it without jargon as “Capitalism is the system which you have to auction your precious time in the market to the lowest available wage to people who don’t care whether you eat well because there is an entire line of people ready to take your spot.”
It’s a bit wordy, but I think it does the job. Every worker has some fear of getting replaced.
The existence of a worker who is “free” in a double sense: free of all constraint or restriction on the scale of his labor power, and free from the land and all means of production in general, a free and unattached laborer, a “proletarian”, who cannot subsist except by selling his labor power.
so i can hopefully explain it to people as: “at its most basic, there is a self-feeding and self-causing loop. a person who owns the means of production can buy the labour power [which you can understand as working hours] of another person. anyone can sell their labor, and under capitalism, everyone must, to make the money they can exchange for the basic necessities of life. if they do not want to participate in this system, it’s death. since it becomes an existential need to sell your labor, the reserve army of laborers is created, where the capitalists, who own the means of production and in essence monopolize money amidst themselves in their firms, [especially since we must buy from them the necessities in the firts place] can simply set the buying price of labor power, there is in effect a very abundant supply of ready workers, because the ultimatum is work or death.” i think…
and then the contradiction also of capitalist firms must always maximize profit and sequently surplus value pocketed, to survive in face of competition , and at a certain point you can pay your workers no less before they start dying or being unable to work (also they can’t buy your commodities that they need for life anymore?)
and at a certain point you can pay your workers no less before they start dying or being unable to work
Not exactly. The individuals of the bourgeoisie aren’t concerned about their workers dying. They are concerned about the proletariat class dying (or being unable to self-reproduce).
You can see this in Occupied Korea or Japan for example. The population is increasingly elder and there is less and less workers having children.
The bourgeois can make a significant percentage of workers be unable to have time to have children, or overwork themselves to death, but they can’t do that for every single worker.
I’ve been thinking about verbosity/garroulessness for several months, since I tend to swing from that to being terse to the point it seems rude. With declining literacy and reading comprehension rates in Western societies, it would behoove us to find a middle ground, since attention spans are also in serious decline, for many varied reasons, not the least of which is physical exhaustion and mental/emotional overwhelm.
I’m struggling with how to find a way towards tercity and unintended rudeness. I need to also work on patience, since impatience fuels intentional rudeness.
Most people are capable of reading long texts as long as they are interested in them. Maybe we can focus on “stepping stones” in order to build this interest.
Informative memes and pamphlets can be used to agitate workers with false consciousness. If they become advanced workers, then they will be able to read The Capital or something.
At the end of the day though, most workers won’t reach advanced levels.
deadass attaching the esoteric meme you did to that post about capital as a true god (or basically the essay just restating WHY capitalism dictates US rather than us being able to delude ourselves that we control its whims was very effective to getting me to read.
i think here you’re also mostly making reference to memes which in effect are like slogans or other heuristics or rhetoric like that that still simplify things in ways that might be erroneous, but are at least effective in capturing people’s attentions and somewhat transmitting the ‘right’ idea (however vulgar or rudimentary it may be at the end compared to the actual full logic/theory)
but at least for me memes about history (not the mainstream whitewashed ones but actual documentation and broadcast of imperial crimes) attached to elementary observations/diamat were able to push me out of the simplistic idealist worldviews i had before (anarcho communist adjacent) and make me desire to Read theory. and i also think that it helped me be able to transmit otherwise very extremely out there ideas to friends who wouldn’t have received the idea of reading lenin or stalin or mao well (even if sometimes i worry at the start my own mistakes might have poisoned their understanding.) i think it’s a good starting point, especially with the most casual or simplistic events like the gazan genocide or even explaining how things like epstein’s island can be an unequivocal bipartisan horror (if usa centric discussion/peers)
Interesting, thanks for the breakdown.
So with that in mind, here’s an attempt to simplify it a bit more in a way similar to the phrase I started with: “In the capitalist US, the capitalists force you to sell your labor power to the market in exchange for temporary relief from starving. In socialist China, organized labor power allows the market to exist in exchange for its consistent contribution to thriving.”
Heavier than the original in terms of “big words”, but maybe a better halfway point between jargon and “losing important distinctions”. What do you think? Better? Worse? Both?
Yeah, that’s great. The only issue I would have is that if you are mentioning the US, then your audience is probably Amerikans, who are very Sinophobic.
But considering that China is getting a lot of good rep, then I think it’s fine to use it as an example.
If you want to drive the point home, why not ask a concrete question like “how did China go from a nation of starving farmers to a global powerhouse in a couple of generations if it wasn’t socialism?” after your definition of Capitalism.
Fair point, I’ll try to keep that in mind. Could probably apply to imperial core audiences in general, asking a rhetorical question like that. Or elsewhere if somebody is being Sinophobic.
I think the phrasing is also general enough about the principles we went over concerning capitalism that “In the capitalist US” could be replaced with “In capitalist Canada” or EU or whatever and still be accurate. It might not land as hard if someone is in an area where unions are stronger, but my impression is that although organized labor is stronger in some parts of the imperial core than others, it’s also been in decline for a while, owed largely to it only having achieved buffer status rather than controlling the state.
That’s a good point.
Adding to your point, in a place with strong unions, maybe it’s good to question why things keep getting worse even with union protection. Unions in Capitalism is just delaying the inevitable (the tendency for the rate of profit to fall).
The Nordic countries are seeing this happen in real time.
i think what’s interesting is that the thick veil of misinfo was super strong in internet/west in 2010s simply because… whatever interactions westerners had with mainlanders was very limited, esp thru internet, and it was really extraordinarily easy to think of them as faceless and unreal if there god forbid were any users on western internet (great firewall is such a benefit to PRC it’s not even funny anymore).
but because of how xhs and rednote became actual things you could use if not the very small flux of people being exposed thru brief tiktok ban, people actually saw chinese as real people and not just imagined suffering drones (before that i really legit think everyone thought that a chinese that was happy in mainland was bot or drone or spy, it doesn’t sound absurd to them, and even now that persists, and i’d say it’s still a majority now). now i feel you see a lot of anglosphere/diaspora chinese (and i suspect a lot are. CIA asset adjacent) making big fusses about social things there so that people never really think it’s too goodl… it feels as if a corrective measure or propaganda, especially since we know how controlled and astroturfed the net is in the west
i think the phase of chinamaxxing had a peak but is now going to dip or plateau if we return to the normal state esp of little exposure or organic interest in PRC, and i’m rather sad the mainstream opinion will revert into the programming we used to have once more. fingers crossed the bigger push and continued huge growth of PRC continues to make containing the china good narrative impossible, even in spite of whatever mediastorm they conjure
So, I have managed to not preach door-to-door for over a month in the religion I’m stuck in (even managed to voice a clear no to an invite). A small achievement.
I also talked to an old high school classmate about programming. I used to be the smart kid but he surpassed me. I’m very happy for him.
I still haven’t mustered up the courage to talk to a communist classmate I know.
all great wins :3 !!!
there was a dawning feeling yesterday of hatred and resentment i had for a friend and i was angry at myself for it. it was something to do with how i can interact with people and have Fun and yet also there’s such a dissonance between who i am and my values and politics and theirs, sometimes insurmountable. not really a matter of her position starting differently from mine mind you, it’s more i feel i can’t actually get through to her in deprogramming anticommunism
the sad part is i feel like i only have what i know through heuristics (i know fairly loosely about imperialism and how it works as a way to maximize profits to escape falling rate of profit, that the system eventually is eating its own tail and destroying us, and then i know about facets of history like imperialist wars and lies the america tells us, but then of course there’s the issue of trying to argue and convince others and actually explaining logic of everything. EDIT: i think what drives me mad is that for other friends i can give them evidence which undermines the capitalist indoctrination so they’re more open. but the friend will outright refuse to accept whatever evidence is contrary to what they already know.)
tldr: it makes me less angry having a friend that initially doesn’t even try to have a political education than one that sources all hers from tiktok and instagram subliminal ‘leftist’ (virulently anticommunist but posturing at anticapitalist) accounts or algorithm that then is extra resistant to actual skepticism around the commonly agreed anti-communist history
she is not a bad friend but every time i have to pretend i give a fuck about taiwan and think it’s in a state where it needs to be liberated from see see pee china i want to kill her
On a blank sheet of paper free from any mark, the freshest and most beautiful characters can be written, the freshest and most beautiful pictures can be painted
i have been incessantly thinking about this mao quote
Feeling kinda sad that I hate pretty much the whole internet but lemmy as of lately. Sometimes I even fear this website will get swarmed by reactionaries and destroyed from within like it happened with leftypol.
I don’t think that’s gonna happen so easily given that Lemmygrad used to be swarmed by libs from other instances (looking at old posts). We have some good admins.
But yeah, the internet is pretty consolidated on the hands of the capitalists now.
Sometimes I miss clowning on them, though.
I can understand that. I also wish to do the clowning one day.
Dead internet theory isn’t just a theory it is a reality. Cloudfare says 57% of all internet requests are from bots. israel is dumping 730 million american dollars into astroturfing this year and who knows how much the Fossil Fuel Industry, the cia and us Millitary industrial complex, the EU’s anti russia slop, and every other imperialist project out there, must be pumping into the same sort of PR campaigns.
These campaigns may eventually start hammering away at lemmy but I think overall the moderation and community structure will make it far harder to astroturf successfully.


















