• 0 Posts
  • 20 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 1st, 2026

help-circle

  • In my work I am hitting the contraditions between internal and external value. A very crude analysis is that if we are to generate surplus value externally (capitalist) then internally we must adhere to as close a communist set of principles as possible as this is the most effective utilisation of commodities as possible. You begin to recognise the small ways that companies try to ensure this contradition does not eat itself up, but knowing that this dichotomy exists is exhausting and empowering. Empowered workers can realise much more value than any shareholder possibly can.


  • Thanks for the reply, as always.

    There to me lies the problem, that against a ML party stands all others, there is no room for any other marxist except that of the ML. I may be too preoccupied with the labelling, as I am sure some would label trotski as coming from a place of marxist-leninism, but he would naturally be vilified as not being a ML at all by others, with people summing up their thoughts, and here I quote ‘first word ‘ice’ and second ‘pick’’.

    As you can see, I am still finding my footing. It seems as a very bludgeoned note that there is still much blame being slung around, as shown in the aforementioned thread on sino/soviet with comrades one-upping each other as being factually incorrect based on incomplete information from limited sources. Heavily encouraged to conduct individual analysis and theory, rightfully so, but it must be pointed towards a specific path.


  • It is interesting that a political theory that hasn’t been especially openly discussed since the first world war, dying along with Luxemborg, isn’t tested or debated openly to determine if it can fit with the material conditions and the people of today. We are violently campist, and refuse to pick and choose or adapt accorsing, seemingly we must to take the approach of the october revolution or nothing else. What worked for China isnt what will work foe Venezuela, and if all revolutions must look the same we really are doomed to fail and break our backs on the same wheels. The party charty of '29 declared anything that was not ML as an enemy, in a world without nuance there are no heavily relations between people, the CCP would not be able to neighbor the SRV.


  • As we speak there is a lovely back and forth regarding the fall of the USSR, where people have characterised the differences between sino/soviet in international relations, and like others that refer to the period of relations with other states and revolutions under stalin which I was shorthanding as stalinism- is that a mischaracterization?


  • Whilst I appreciate the comment, taking the view that ‘do not think X else it will not lead to Y’ is unhelpful and a gross simplification, by this it would be true to say that stalinism is doomed to fail. It also reads that in order for communism to be successful it must be immoral by using your own comment. This community is a wondrous place, but the memes channel usually punches left and doesnt punch right.











  • When people are ready to engage in some deeper thoughts, then can start going into theory but until then just chipping away at the walls. If there are just one or two issues that people are really chewing over then lets chop it up together. What is going to help me, as today I just right my thoughts down, is that when I have a computer I can start filing away my and organising my notes. When the wall of text show downs happen then I too and copy and paste and furiously type away! This will definitely help me build a more complete understanding and allow me to stay cohesive in my analysis.

    You’re fighting the good fight comrade, keep it up!



  • This is the way, comrade! I am also planting the seeds of doubt. I got hit with the ‘are pro-russia’ and ‘concentration camps in xinjang’, and have been quietly flipping the script. “I don’t know that its pro-russia but more like anti-US’, and the alternative is what? Just keep voting for the status-quo? Thats pro-genocide”. (Voting for the workers party). “Concentration camps for that many people?? That would be fucking HUGE and you could see that from space.” (rikers comparison). It starts by helping people see that what they are led to believe is them being led by someone. We can do this together :)