I’m splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I’m hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

Part 1: The problem

Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they’re terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it’s not addressed.

Lemmy’s answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don’t like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that’s not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

Part 2: My solution

My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we’ll just end up with another Reddit.

  • Kichae@piefed.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    So, your solution is… cronyism? Because this just sounds like creating a special class of power-player users and a smoke screen for them.

  • JTode@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    I think the federated nature of things will shake this out, if admins/mods (there seems to be some confusion about which term to use) get too nuts. Reddit has a legendary shithead Mod on the main Grateful Dead sub, but there’s an alternate GD sub where a group that is smaller, but sufficient to form a community, gathers.

    In the case of here, someone can start a community with the same name on a different Instance, and just like those two Dead subs, it’s not a one or the other proposition for users, they can sub both or either. People will gravitate to the community with the best moderation that creates the best discourse.

    Bottom line, this place is in a lot less danger from the problem you describe than Reddit. There are built-in pressure valves, seems to me.

  • Die4Ever@retrolemmy.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    4 days ago

    Don’t like the mods at World?

    That’s admins not moderators. Admins are for instances, moderators are for communities.

    Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that’s not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail.

    Define “fail”? Niche communities will have a limited audience of course, but if the moderators of a big community suck then people will move. It doesn’t take years to saturate the Threadiverse audience, the people are either here or they aren’t, but the people that are here and interested will join your community pretty quickly.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    Voting is really not much different from moving to a different community. Vote with your feet.

    • corsicanguppy@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 days ago

      nearly all communities or instances fail.

      Define “fail”?

      Yeah. It’s not like there’s a quarterly review for coolness or the sub goes away.

      The thing that kills a sub is impatience by the founder.

  • benno@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    4 days ago

    upvotes are way too easy to manipulate on fedi so if you really want democratic elections you would need a better system. but lets just keep it simple

  • pseudo@jlai.lu
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    Thank you for sharing.

    I disagree with the problem hence with the solution. Because Lemmy isn’t centralised the bigger instances are more into a oligopoly situation that in a monopoly. Therefore it is not easy but definitly doable to move a community from one instance to the other to free our selves from the mods. Of course, we cannt be sure without an example. If anyone think of some case, I’m listening.

    You also seems to simply the way moderation acts. Moderation happened at the instance level and the community level and not only is the rule inforces by a different team (or single overworked moderator) when you switch community or instances but the set of rule is different.

  • But that’s not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen

    It literally takes as few as 2 people to have a meaningful discussion, so the idea it needs to be some kind of massively large site is already a false premise.

      • But if you post it to a public forum, it’s like hitting “reply all.”

        Maybe the 2 users in Sergio’s Juggalo community already say enough that spectators agree with one or the other and don’t feel the need to add anything more. 🤷‍♂️

      • Kichae@piefed.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        4 days ago

        But with it being on a publicly accessible forum, there’s the implicit invitation to join the discussion.

    • Sergio@piefed.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 days ago

      Yeah, agreed. In terms of niche communities I know…

      • There are like 5-6 of us posting weekly on !gothindustrial@lemmy.world with occasionals popping in. We get a regular number of upvotes (329 Monthly Active Users) tho not a lot of discussion/comments
      • on !sumo@lemmy.world there’s only like 3-4 daily regulars during tourneys and we have more comments than upvotes sometimes, but it’s a fun community
      • on the other hand, !juggalos@lemmy.world is pretty dead because there were only 2 of us (there was a third person but they disappeared) and I think we got bored posting to each other

      So in terms of a rock bottom number of “engaged community members” to keep a community alive, I’d say it’s closer to 6 than 2. But yeah, it doesn’t have to be a massively large number.

  • TragicNotCute@lemmy.worldM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    I don’t think this is a good idea. I’d encourage you to look at my comment history in this community specifically. Every comment I’ve left in my official capacity is a direct result of at least one user report. I prefer a very light touch moderation style, where I address rule breaking content when reported but otherwise let the community manage itself.

    Those comments I left are not terribly popular, and I think that’s the heart of the problem. Running a community effectively and maintaining some sense of order is not generally a very popular activity. Do we really want to make moderation a popularity contest? Beyond that, I don’t post much in fediverse, does that mean I’m ill suited to being a mod here? I don’t think so.

    I agree in general that poor moderation can be a problem, but letting the most popular posters run the community doesn’t seem like the fix.

  • Auster@kbin.earth
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    Discussing the solution would be to accept the premise. And the premise I think is flawed, pun intended, so let’s adress it first.

    Majority of instances are extremely small, so if you are correct on the surface analysis that most fail, it may simply be people giving up on their venture for going to a place more stable and that they don’t have to manage themselves.

    Also surface analysis is another problem by itself because the premises for it can be faulty, and saying as if it’s a certainty can help spread misconceptions. And there’s also the problem of the sensationalistic tone.

    And on communities failing, define failing, please. Some may indeed, but what if they simply represent a topic so niche it rarely warrants discussions?

    And on migrating, if the very top is problematic, voting out can be hard too. Even more so if it’s the guy paying the bills or managing the infraestructure. And also example comes from the above, as the saying goes, so users cather to the culture they want to see fostered by the administration.

    Furthermore, still on voting, who’s to say, if voting is implemented, bot and paid actor accounts aren’t made discretely over time to rig them?

    Also, what works to one group may not work to another, or even to the same group in different periods.

    And still on migrating overall, since here’s a network, not simply just a bunch of social medias aware of one another, if you make an account on a new platform, there’s a kickstart of potential users since they’re still in the network.

    And regarding the network aspect, using a software with microblogging integration such as Mbin, Piefed, Catodon or Friendica can give an even further push, since then you can use hashtags, boosts, following besides subscribing, community packs, etc.

    Also on being a network, you can use relays, such as Threadirator and the other project with a same purpose I always forget the name. That helps making it appear on the connected instances.

    And with the problems I could notice out of the way, no onto the proposed solution alternative:

    The fediverse is a network, so you are free to make an instance to try that yourself. Or also to approach instance administrators to see if they’d be willing to experiment, since people can be rather approachable if you ask them directly.

    And if the idea works out, similar to how historically it goes, people will copy the model. But a beautiful idea on paper means nothing without concrete examples. And as it’s presented, it sounds more like a liability than a proper model.

    • Lumidaub@feddit.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 days ago

      Well to be fair, there doesn’t seem to be a good reason to contribute anything that I can see because there’s no topic. What kind of posts do you expect?

      • CombatWombat@feddit.online
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        4 days ago

        Me? I dunno. I was trying my best to play along but I never quite figured out what the idea was. I dropped by their discord and the people who run it for other platforms were similarly puzzled. The whole thing was kinda weird.

  • Raphael@communick.news
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    FUCK NO!

    Votes are never an indicator of quality.

  • HubertManne@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    I don’t even like leaning to heavily on moderation. I want emphasis to be on users ability to curate their feed.

    • Kichae@piefed.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 days ago

      And I want emphasis on websites-as-community-hubs. Which means we have some significantly opposing desires.

      Now what?

    • Die4Ever@retrolemmy.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 days ago

      That won’t work because casual users don’t want to do anything. The 90/9/1 rule says that 90% of users don’t want to do anything, every extra click required scares them away.

  • kylie_kraft@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    wow, that may be the worst idea for the direction of lemmy since the Tesseract guy. bravo

      • kylie_kraft@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        4 days ago

        I kind of agree with the others here. the current system is fine, but if you don’t like it, make your own instance. lemmy has some problem mods, but they are far from the biggest issue

  • SorteKanin@feddit.dk
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    There is no need for elections, cause you can just choose whichever admin or mods you want. It’s not a democracy, you just choose what you like best and everyone has the same choice. That’s better than democracy cause nobody has to compromise.

    If you think mods or admins are doing a bad job, choose different mods or admins or become your own admin.

      • cecilkorik@piefed.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        4 days ago

        Who says the community won’t choose the same as you? And if they don’t, are you really sure you want or need that community? Move forward with the people who agree with you, don’t covet the ones who don’t. If your ideas and differences which are driving you to fragment the community are not aligned with the community as it stands, yes they might end up lonely and unpopular, and that might just be because they’re not compelling ideas or they’re not offering anything that most people want or are interested in. Inertia is not necessarily a bad thing, it’s just how the laws of physics work.

      • SorteKanin@feddit.dk
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        4 days ago

        If other people choose differently than you, then yea obviously you’re not going to be in the same place. That’s everyone’s own choice. Live with it or choose the same as the community you want.

        • Kichae@piefed.ca
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          4 days ago

          But how can I have things my way, and also ensure that you have things my way, too, if we’re in different places?? Huh? Didja ever even think about that?