Oh my gawd, it’s Hasan Hasan Piker, the guy that BadEmpandadadadada keeps railing about, bruhs! Yeah, he’s just another entryist and social-chauvinist.
Can anyone explain this to me better, specifically what Lenin is talking about here and how it relates? Haven’t gotten to S&R extensively, yet.
Can anyone explain this to me better, specifically what Lenin is talking about here…
He is talking about the leaders of the Second International, most prominently Karl Kautsky and Georgi Plekhanov.
These people were right-wing/reformist revisionists of the Marxist theory. Karl Kautsky, today, is widely considered the father of ‘Democratic Socialism’. The sector of the left that believes socialist revolution can one day happen ‘spontaneously’ if the socialists keep pushing for economically populist policies via the electoral avenues available in a bourgeois democracy. Lenin calls this erroneous practice Economism. It deviates from Marx and Lenin’s advocacy for a forceful overthrow of the bourgeois state and replacing it with a dictatorship of the proletariat. It also opposes Lenin’s theory of the necessity of a revolutionary Vanguard.
The particular reason why Lenin called them ‘social-chauvinists’ in the aforementioned text is because they sided with the nationalist policies of their respective bourgeois governments during the first world war instead of taking a greater anti-war stance.
and how it relates?
Hasan Piker is a DemSoc who loves to larp as a Marxist. He often misinterprets Marxist theory to disparage the critics of democratic politicians like Graham Platner and AOC.
Ah… Should I start S&R after WITBD? I was thinking Foundations of Leninism or something else, but S&R seems to expand on WITBD.
There is a lot of development that happens in Lenin’s writings in the period between “What Is To Be Done?” and “The State and Revolution”, most importantly the writing of “Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism”, though that one may be tough for a beginner.
This is also the period where his writings are perhaps most applicable to the current phase of revolutionary organizing that we are in right now, where we are not yet in revolutionary conditions and we still need to build the party and its messaging apparatus. “Two Tactics of Social-Democracy in the Democratic Revolution” might be a good transitional read from this period to State and Revolution.
After S&R read “The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky”, which is a direct continuation of S&R, as well as “Left Wing Communism: An Infantile Disorder”. I would also recommend reading “The Tax in Kind” at some point because it clears up many ultra-left misconceptions.
He’s commenting on Kautsky and his ilk, who had at the time been claiming to be Marxists, yet their entire political project was largely anti-Marxist, and they were also engaging in revisionism of Marx’s works. Effectively attempting to neuter Marx’s revolutionary analysis. At that time, the Second International was a prominent site of radical politics and political development, and Kautsky was gaining some influence within it.
People and capitalism stay the same
nothing new under the sun






